Post by abseptember17 on May 7, 2013 11:55:28 GMT -5
H really wants a separate tub and shower in our master. I'd love to do that too but the space is a bit tight. It is currently set up that way but the shower is really tiny. I was looking into options and came across some photos of baths with the tub in the back and the shower in the front (you have to walk to shower to get to the tub). What do you think of this layout? Our toilet would not be in that same location. The overall width would be 8'. Would you like this or prefer a traditional tub/shower combo or just shower?
Not a fan - it looks very locker room to me. I think the point of having a separate tub is to look a bit more grand and luxurious. I'm not sure what benefit is gained from having them side-by-side like that.
looks kind of like the spa to me. On one hand, I like it because I'm the kind of person who feels like I need to shower after a soak in the tub. On the other hand, I don't like that it looks like a spa.
Also, it seems like they tried to cram a luxury shower into a space that didn't permit. The toilet is so close - it looks cramped, and it kills the luxury of multiple shower heads. Also it looks like they blew the budget on the shower and tile and didn't have enough to really go the distance with a nice tub etc. If you want a separate tub/ shower, I feel like it should be a statement tub, like a clawfoot or other kind of beautiful tub. I don't see the point in doing it with a standard tub.
Why can't you turn the tub perpendicular to the shower? 3' for the tub still leaves 5' for the shower.
Here's some of the ideas the contractor gave us. This will show the layout/dimensions of the bath. The door to enter is by the vanity. I'm VERY open to other layout suggestions, so if you have one, let me know!
looks kind of like the spa to me. On one hand, I like it because I'm the kind of person who feels like I need to shower after a soak in the tub. On the other hand, I don't like that it looks like a spa.
Also, it seems like they tried to cram a luxury shower into a space that didn't permit. The toilet is so close - it looks cramped, and it kills the luxury of multiple shower heads. Also it looks like they blew the budget on the shower and tile and didn't have enough to really go the distance with a nice tub etc. If you want a separate tub/ shower, I feel like it should be a statement tub, like a clawfoot or other kind of beautiful tub. I don't see the point in doing it with a standard tub.
The space we have is much wider and like I said, the toilet won't be in that location. It's just an example of a layout option. I agree that if we did it, the tub would have to be more upscale. Here's other examples of the same layout, although ours wouldn't look like this either.
Post by abseptember17 on May 7, 2013 20:50:53 GMT -5
A big shower is priority... ok not even big, just decent sized. I thought his drawings for the tub looked pretty large. A stand alone tub is an option that I hadn't really thought of, so you might have something there. Once my LO is done with baths, the tub won't get used much. The wall across from the shower is empty. We were hoping to keep the toilet where it is to avoid adding to the plumbing costs... but it could be moved if it made a BIG difference in the layout. There is also a window towards the end of the toilet (add location, we have a roman shade up) that makes things a bit more complicated. Based on what the contractor said, the sinks really need to stay where they are. Is there a good website I can go on to play around with the layout? Thanks!
Every time you took a shower it would spray into the tub and you'd have a huge area to have to clean on a more regular basis because of it.
Constructability of that layout is way more complicated than just a tub or shower or tub/shower combo. Waterproofing that whole area costs a lot more. Corners are the area you will get leaks and need to take extra precautions so adding a tub surround just introduced a lot of unnecessary corners. Tub surrounds are usually not waterproofed at all so you would need to be all over your contractor to ensure they are building it correctly or you will have a leak.
A shower and tub combo like this is called a "wet room" which means all of the walls above the tub as well need to be waterproofed = $$$
What your first picture and second Houzz link shower are actually curbless wet rooms which would mean lowering your floor to include a below the floor pre-slope so the finished slope matches the rest of the floor. That is a ton of work to do and requires that your entire bathroom floor be waterproofed along with a few inches up the wall (essentially your entire bathroom becomes the shower pan and curb). Also very expensive.