So, on one hand...Awww, they mailed me a "Happy Mother-to-be day" for Mother's Day as I'm expecting my first. And it's really, really nice since this I went through losses in the past and Mother's Day has always been hell for me.
But, on the other hand, I'm side-eyeing the name on the address. The backstory is they are pretty stubborn and intrusive people and I've always butted heads with them. I ALWAYS assumed I would never take my husband's name, so I kept my name. They had a huge issue about this and I've never heard the end of it. It's just one of the MANY things that have driven a wedge between us. I've been told "You can't be our DIL if you don't take our name" and BIL has told me that DH should have left me and never married me once he found out I wound't take his name. BIL has never introduced me to people he knows as "this is my SIL". Instead, it's been "This is my brother's wife" and he told me he never will since my name is different.
So the card is addressed "Mrs. Odonata H's Last Name". ^o)
God damn it they are so passive aggressive!
I guess I'll just be happy about it and not say anything. What is the point, right? They did a nice thing, that's all that matters. But it does still get under my skin. Errr.
If you know it has been/will be an issue for them why are you surprised?
I would focus on the NICE thing they did and just accept that the name thing will always be a sore point. But you already knew that.
Very true. I guess it'll never end. I mean, it's one thing to not be happy about it. I know we're going to butt heads on a ton of stuff and just have to accept that about each other. They don't have to rub it in.
Guess I need thicker skin because they'll probably not stop with the jabbing.
Can't wait for after the baby comes and they whole drama about raising it Catholic vs. Atheist (we are) comes up AGAIN. H and I are sure that as soon as they are alone with our child they're going to rush of and have an emergency baptism! lol.
If you know it has been/will be an issue for them why are you surprised?
I would focus on the NICE thing they did and just accept that the name thing will always be a sore point. But you already knew that.
Very true. I guess it'll never end. I mean, it's one thing to not be happy about it. I know we're going to butt heads on a ton of stuff and just have to accept that about each other. They don't have to rub it in.
Guess I need thicker skin because they'll probably not stop with the jabbing.
Can't wait for after the baby comes and they whole drama about raising it Catholic vs. Atheist (we are) comes up AGAIN. H and I are sure that as soon as they are alone with our child they're going to rush of and have an emergency baptism! lol.
H's coworkers ILs did this. They offered to babysit so coworker and his wife could have a night away and they had a family friend who was a priest baptize their son. Needless to say, coworker was furious and they cut ILs out of their lives.
Where is your DH in all this? What does he do when his brother introduces you like that?
I didn't change my name when I got married. One of DH's relatives made a comment about how we weren't really married because I didn't change my name and DH shut that shit down immediately.
I'd be pissed since it's a passive/aggressive dig.
My very sweet FIL started sending things to Mr. & Mrs. DH's name after we got married, but he's normal - I sent him a very polite note that I didn't change my name (which he knew, but I think wasn' paying much attention) and it's never been an issue since - you know, since he's not an asshole.
I would just try to not let it bother you too much since they are not going to change.
ignore ignore ignore. That's how I deal with my IL's. The worst thing you can do if this is a passive aggressive jab is make a big deal out of it. That is what they are looking for.
My mother couldn't handle the fact that her SISTER didn't change her name when she married. So, 30 YEARS later, my mother fell to pieces when we tried to address my aunt's invitation to my wedding. To pieces. Somehow, writing HerFirst Last and HisFirst Last was all wrong, wrong, wrong. I think I had to do it where she couldn't see me.
So the fact that they did what they always do .. NOT shocking. At all.
Nice card. Even if they addressed it with the wrong name.
* And PS: You will always win this one. Because it's YOUR name to choose. They will never be right, no matter how many cards they address. You will always. be. right.
I'm as mature as a 12 year old most of the time so I would send it back "return to sender no one at this address with this name"
I would also give my husband as many blow jobs as it would take for him to write it and send it back so they know it was his handwriting and he was on my side.
Where is your DH in all this? What does he do when his brother introduces you like that?
I didn't change my name when I got married. One of DH's relatives made a comment about how we weren't really married because I didn't change my name and DH shut that shit down immediately.
He's often not been around when these things are said to me. Otherwise, he's told them it's not their business what I do with my name and he loves me and wants to be with me so they need to get over it.
Where is your DH in all this? What does he do when his brother introduces you like that?
I didn't change my name when I got married. One of DH's relatives made a comment about how we weren't really married because I didn't change my name and DH shut that shit down immediately.
Ditto.
This is not only an IL's problem.
Oh please. Unless you are privy to super secret information not included anywhere in this post, nothing OP has written has indicated one way or another how her husband reacts to this.
They're never going to change their minds. I'd just let it go - if it bothers you they win. I hate losing.
(eta: I'm dumb and mixed two posts)
Yes. I've just started to blatantly ignore any jabs they give me - like I didn't even hear them. So I won't say anything. I hate losing too! But that's why I'm on here bitching about it so I can vent it out to the internet and be over it later.
They are totally the type who will jab and push just to get their way - even if it means I won't change my name they'll still get just as much gratification if they feel they make me upset about it.
I think I'll call MIL and thank her for the card. Just to be "nice".
H just got home and saw the card and said "oh, that's nice" and I showed him the address and he rolled his eyes and said "well, you know them, what can you do?" He's right.
Where is your DH in all this? What does he do when his brother introduces you like that?
I didn't change my name when I got married. One of DH's relatives made a comment about how we weren't really married because I didn't change my name and DH shut that shit down immediately.
He's often not been around when these things are said to me. Otherwise, he's told them it's not their business what I do with my name and he loves me and wants to be with me so they need to get over it.
I think he needs to tell them again. Seriously.
I get that some people are all "this isn't that big a deal" but to me, when someone refused to call me by my name and instead calls me by a name they think I should have, that is disrespectful and really, quite rude.
I would start calling MIL "Mabel" since that is the name you think she be called, who cares if it isn't her name. She doesn't seem to care that she calls you by a name that isn't yours.
Same with asshole BIL, "this is the idiot who is related to my husband? Oh, why do I call him an idiot? Because apparently he can't remember that I am his sister-in-law because I kept my maiden name."
People act like assholes because no one bothers to call them on their crap, especially in families. As I have gotten older, my tolerance for the BS has dropped and I no longer give family a pass just because they are family. If I wouldn't let a stranger treat me badly, I sure as heck won't allow family, people who are supposed to care about me do it.
Oh please. Unless you are privy to super secret information not included anywhere in this post, nothing OP has written has indicated one way or another how her husband reacts to this.
Thanks for that support. I read those and thought "oh here we go, it's going to turn into my H is a dick post"
He laid it out there a long time ago that it's none of their business and the way we deal with them is to ignore, ignore, ignore. It doesn't matter what H says to them, they don't respect him enough to stop anyway. There would be no point in him calling them up to complain about the name on the card, ESPECIALLY given it was such a nice thing to send. That's just a big 'ol can of worms there. Actually, that's probably why they did it. It would make me look like an ass to complain.
I wouldn't thank them for their dig of asstacularness. It was purposeful and there's no etiquette requirement I'm aware of that mandates a thank you for a card.
Make the baby's middle name your maiden name. Will drive them apepoop.
I actually think they will be OK with this. It's really what the last name is that has them all fired up.
Besides, I think the religion thing down the line will drive them apepoop. CANNOT WAIT for that. I'm sure we'll have many methods of driving them crazy once this kid gets here. lol
Which is fine b/c H has already many times said "they don't like it, they don't have to be around us or their grandkid" so we're well prepared to take that step.
I actually think they will be OK with this. It's really what the last name is that has them all fired up.
Besides, I think the religion thing down the line will drive them apepoop. CANNOT WAIT for that. I'm sure we'll have many methods of driving them crazy once this kid gets here. lol
Which is fine b/c H has already many times said "they don't like it, they don't have to be around us or their grandkid" so we're well prepared to take that step.
I hope you/your H put them in their place when they give you a hard time.
We do. But it doesn't stop them. They actually called us over (in other words at us down) a few months ago to tell us what bad kids we are because we don't stop by unannounced and they feel we should do that often. We told them 1) that's a crazy expectation and this scolding was beyond inappropriate and 2) we distance ourselves because they are so crazy.
I don't think I could have much of a relationship if they were that disrespectful to me over my name.
And I don't have much of a relationship with them at all. We've been married almost 3 years now and they knew this about me for a whole year before so it's almost 4 years that this "name thing" has been an issue with them. There are a ton other things about them that have driven me away (I could seriously write a book) and I've gotten to the point that I dislike these people so much I couldn't change my name to theirs just because I don't want to be related to them.
Yet, they are annoyed that I'm not close to them. They're that cracked that they don't get that when they are assholes to people those people aren't going to like them back.
Actually, once I told them I was expecting they've been just the nicest. I guess they are kissing ass to make sure they have baby time. I guess MIL just could not bring herself to write my REAL name on the card. That would somehow be admitting that I'm right and in their crack-head world, if they demand something is one way it's that way, no matter what. TBH, she didn't even write my whole name, it was Mrs. first initial, H's last name so I've been reduced to an initial, I guess.
So hey, if they decide to throw in my face again why I'm not so close to them, I can honestly say I can't consider myself family to people who can't respect my own name and wishes.
My in-laws are generally nice people and accept me as their DIL, but they always address mail to with DH's last name. It irritates me because they know I didn't change my name, but I just roll my eyes and move on because we get along. Although they have recently started come around a little and now address my mail to me with a hyphenated name. I don't think I could have much of a relationship if they were that disrespectful to me over my name.
My MIL is missing a few marbles and a bitch so it is never clear what her intentions are. I did take my husband's name, for the purposes of example we will say his name is Jones and my maiden name is Smith. She has addressed things to Violet and MrViolet Smith-Jones, Violet Jones-Smith, Violet Smith Jones, and my favorite Violet and MrViolet Smith. I thought she was trying to be passive aggressive until that one.
Make the baby's middle name your maiden name. Will drive them apepoop.
Or hypenate! Smith-Jones.
OP - my mom always addresses cards to "Mrs. AliHubby AliHubbyLastname". I tend to agree it's an older person thing. I try not to take everything as a personal slight against me.
Yeah that would bother me. I would not call them to thank them for this passive-aggressive card. I would say nothing. If they ask if you received it, say, "Yes, I did." End of story.
Is it really that weird to introduce your brother's wife as your brother's wife...?
No, it's not. But it's hard to explain...it's the way he does it.
I guess I can say that it's something I've noticed over the past three years - I've never once heard him say SIL. So I brought it up in passing like *laugh* so hey, you can just say SIL and not "brother's wife", you know!" *laugh* silly....
And that's when I was told I'm not his SIL b/c of my last name. :?
But whatever, BIL is just as much of an ass as his parents. He's said a few doozies to me that has me pretty much seeing him as a person I'm obligated to be around at family gatherings. The same with MIL and FIL. I LOVE BIL's GF, though. And she sticks up for me when they bash me when DH and I aren't around, which I hear happens often.
I remember back in the day when it was unheard of NOT to take your husband's last name. I remember my own mother referring to herself as Mrs. Richard Flex'smaidenname. She didn't even use her own first name!
Those days are long gone. Your ILs sound like dinosaurs.
"Why would you ruin perfectly good peanuts by adding candy corn? That's like saying hey, I have these awesome nachos, guess I better add some dryer lint." - Nonny