Best girl scout cookie

[mala]

In honor of Cat, which is your favorite? I made it so you can select up to 2 cookies if you can't decide.

Savannah Smiles
Trefoils
Do-si-dos
Samoas
Tagalongs
Thin Mints
Something else
I have no soul and hate girl scout cookies.

~~~
Vomit free since '93!

[unclejesse]

They used to make these vanilla cookie sandwiches with raspberry jam inside that were THE BOMB.  But Thin Mints are my hands down favorite.  Samoas are good too.  

[browneyedhunni85]

Samoas!

[ruby412]

I freakin' love GS cookies. What the heck are Savannah Smiles though? I only know of that as a fabulous 80s movie.

[carawestt]

Samoas or the lemon ones.

[Deleted]

Thin Mints 4 lyfe!!!

[Deleted]

Lemon!!!! But then they changed them so they aren't as good as they used to be.

[AndyCohen]

Samoas hands down. They are followed closely by tagalongs.

I love thin mints and trefoils, but Keebler makes a decent thin mint knockoff and I can get good shortbread anywhere.

[ashleydl83]

Samoas are my absolute favorite. I'll take frozen thin mint too.

[bebeetmoi]

Oooooooh this was a tough choice! Samoas and Tagalongs are my favorites, but if I had to choose one, I'd say Samoas.

[vthokie]

Jan 26, 2013 22:12:31 GMT -5 bebeetmoi said:

Oooooooh this was a tough choice! Samoas and Tagalongs are my favorites, but if I had to choose one, I'd say Samoas.

This!

[cat19]

Nothing beats a frozen tagalong. NOTHING.

[lolaburns]

I LOVE Samoas...but I also love Thin Mints! Don't make me choose!


Sent from the bottom of a Clorox bottle.

[lolaburns]

I also can demolish a box of the peanut butter ones.


Sent from the bottom of a Clorox bottle.

[AndyCohen]

Jan 26, 2013 22:12:11 GMT -5 ashleydl83 said:

Samoas are my absolute favorite. I'll take frozen thin mint too.

Yes, thin mints must be frozen.

[eav2c]

My favorite I haven't been able to find in years. They are a shortbread type cookie with lemon icing in the middle. Savannah Smiles don't compare, IMO. I have three boxes of those in my pantry from last year. They should probably be tossed, lol.

[kkfeb04]

Jan 26, 2013 22:13:23 GMT -5 @chelsmonster said:

Jan 26, 2013 22:09:27 GMT -5 AndyCohen said:

Samoas hands down. They are followed closely by tagalongs.

This!

This also!

[hass2001]

Is it that time of year again? I'm so excited because I missed last year. Tagalongs are my favorite with samoas and thin mints tied for 2nd.

[creamsiclechica]

Hass said it best!

In one of the movie theatres in the mall where I grew up, those pesky girl scouts would set up a table outside and sell boxes. I'd always buy two boxes of tagalongs before I went in to see a movie, and never once did either of those boxes make it out of the film.

[gmoneymommy]

THIN MINTS!!!!

[pinkpeony6210]

Thin mints!

[The Foozzler]

Jan 26, 2013 22:17:44 GMT -5 cat19 said:

Nothing beats a frozen tagalong Thin Mint. NOTHING.

FTFY

[The Foozzler]

I teach elementary school. I say yes to every girl in my class that asks. So many cookies!

[lauranicole91]

Tagalongs for lyfe!! Dosidos are second. I don't like Carmel, coconut, or mint so the other popular ones don't make my list.

For the past couple years they've had these ones called thanks-a-lottas I think. They are the shortbread with one chocolate on one side. Yum.

[katie]

Jan 26, 2013 22:23:26 GMT -5 lolaburns said:

I LOVE Samoas...but I also love Thin Mints! Don't make me choose!


Sent from the bottom of a Clorox bottle.

Me too! 

I have no idea what a Tagalong or Savannah smiles are. 

[mscatra]

Do-Si-Dos have overtaken Thin Mints for me. The last box I got of TMs just didn't taste as good as I remembered. I might need to try them again this year for verification purposes And now that I don't hate coconut as much as I did as a kid, I might need to try Samoas, too. For research.

[mscatra]

Jan 27, 2013 7:38:06 GMT -5 katie said:

Me too! 

I have no idea what a Tagalong or Savannah smiles are. 

baking.about.com/od/familybaking/a/girlscoutcookie_2.htm

Hmmm.....my research might need to include Tagalongs as well.  I can't remember what they taste like.  Let's blame mom brain.

[katie]

Jan 27, 2013 7:43:40 GMT -5 mscatra said:

Do-Si-Dos have overtaken Thin Mints for me. The last box I got of TMs just didn't taste as good as I remembered. I might need to try them again this year for verification purposes And now that I don't hate coconut as much as I did as a kid, I might need to try Samoas, too. For research.

Thanks! I saw Cats thread after I posted. I only eat thin mints and samoas so that's why I didn't recognize the name. Shortbreads are good too but I wouldn't buy lemon or peanut butter cookies. 

[mscatra]

I (heart) peanut butter.

[The Foozzler]

Trefoils with nutella. You're welcome.