I was interested in this too, and was thisclose to getting it as a VIB perk from an online sephora order, but ended up getting the stuff I needed in the store instead. Good to know you like it!
Post by msamyfarrahfowler on Jul 22, 2014 11:03:26 GMT -5
I've been using Benefit's mascara for the last few days and I'm not impressed. It thickens, but does nothing for curling. I'm still curious about this eyeliner though.
Post by veruca5839 on Jul 22, 2014 11:21:24 GMT -5
Thanks for posting. I have been on the fence about this since it came out. I keep seeing a lot of negative reviews though, which has kept me from purchasing.
It's not been as easy for me to use as advertised, but I like it too. It makes doing a cat's eye ridiculously easy, and the black is intense, if a bit prone to flakiness.
I love how dark and matte it is, and I don't have an issue with flaking. It stays put on me. I wouldn't say it's easy to use, and there's definitely a learning curve with it. Once I got the hang of it, I was hooked.
I find that it's only slightly harder to control than a liquid liner, but I like the look of it much better.
A few months ago all my magazines raved about this liner. I ran to Sephora only to find out it hadn't been released yet. I completely forgot about it, so I'm so happy to see this post and the good reviews.
I've been using Benefit's mascara for the last few days and I'm not impressed. It thickens, but does nothing for curling. I'm still curious about this eyeliner though.
Ditto on the mascara. I saw rave reviews on they're real mascara but I haven't been impressed since I bought my first tube last week. Still waiting for that holy grail mascara for my sad lashes.
I'm still loyal and keep going back to the Stila waterproof liquid liner with the felt tip. I've tried SO MANY and it's still my best IMO.
This is what I use too... LOVE IT! The Benefit liner peaked my interest... until I looked up their hashtag on IG. Either people don't know how to use it or it doesn't give the look that the Stila gives me... a straight line lol.
I'm still loyal and keep going back to the Stila waterproof liquid liner with the felt tip. I've tried SO MANY and it's still my best IMO.
I've never tried it. Is it an angled felt tip?
Yeah it's like a tapered felt tip. Gives a great line and so easy to use and lasts all day but although it says waterproof it comes off easily when washing my face or using makeup remover. Definitely check it out. It's my absolute fave!
I'm still loyal and keep going back to the Stila waterproof liquid liner with the felt tip. I've tried SO MANY and it's still my best IMO.
This is what I use too... LOVE IT! The Benefit liner peaked my interest... until I looked up their hashtag on IG. Either people don't know how to use it or it doesn't give the look that the Stila gives me... a straight line lol.
Completely agree. I use it every day and have tried several. I was very intrigued about the benefit but the reviews have really been mixed. I may just not mess with a good thing.