S/O PB&J- what kind of PB and what kind of jelly?

[rjamz]

Crunchy or creamy?
Jelly or preserves?
What flavor?

[rjamz]

Crunchy 4-Eva
Preserves if they're on sale.
Strawberry

[laurack]

creamy PB, natural (the brand doesn't matter. Right now we have Teddies, and sunbutter)

I usually try to buy the jelly that is sweetened with fruit juice. I think it's "smuckers all fruit" we have now, but whole foods and TJs also have one

I prefer strawberry

Raspberry would be fine too, but seedless. I don't like seedy jam

[honeybee503]

Creamy PB. I just buy the store brand.

Polaner fruit spread for jelly. I like grape best, but Natalie will eat any flavor.

[thedahliharpa]

I like crunchy but we buy creamy for the kids.
No salt natural type from TJs
Organic strawberry jelly from TJs

[kdrake8]

Crunchy!
Preserves preferably
Any! I'm not picky

[laurensmomma]

Creamy natural. I don't want no crunchies in my nutter.

Strawberry preserves.

[formerlyllizzyb]

Creamy. Red plum jam if I'm having the J with my PB. I really enjoy PB and honey sandwiches.

[beelove]

Crunchy, salted, all natural (just peanuts and salt)
Preserves
Blackberry

[AndyCohen]

These peanut butters specifically (both are smooth). If I did do J, it would be preserves for sure.

[kandrze1]

Peter Pan crunchy peanut butter and Smuckers raspberry preserves.
I don't like the seedless jam at all. Sometimes I like homemade strawberry or blackberry if I can find it at a farmers market.

[puppylove64]

Crunchy always!!!! Au natural

Strawberry

[DaphneStrauss]

I like crunchy pb but we've been buying creamy for M. The natural kind, no salt added from TJs. And cherry or raspberry preserves.

[carawestt]

Crunchy PB, strawberry jelly.

[TrudyCampbell]

Natural PB/creamy, strawberry preserves

[melis74]

Creamy
Preserves - Jelly does not spread and annoys me.
Strawberry

[mumegs]

Creamy Jif
Whatever kind of jelly doesn't have the chunks of fruit in it, ew

[tennisgal]

I was always a crunchy. MH was always creamy. Once we got married, I just switched to creamy so I wouldn't have to buy 2 different jars at the store! #lazy

[playswithsquirrels]

Creamy Jif PB and strawberry jelly for lyfe!!

[creamsiclechica]

Crunchy natural peanut butter. Preserves. I like all kinds!

[Deleted]

I use almond butter or Nutella. I add honey sometimes and then I use a raspberry or some type of preserves.

[The Foozzler]

Creamy only.

I will use jam or jelly or preserves

Any flavor as long as it isn't grape.

[katie]

Peter Pan whipped peanut butter and it's SO good!
Strawberry preserves

[rubber pants]

Grape jelly for life!!!!

What is wrong with all of you strawberry PBJ lovers?? Lol

[rjamz]

What is up with all you creamy peanut butter people??? Extra super duper chunky!

[artgal84]

Crunchy
Strawberry, triple berry or plum preserves

[jamaga2583]

Creamy always. I prefer homemade strawberry jam, but if that's not an option, suckers strawberry jam or raspberry preserves will suffice. Bonus points if it is on extra squishy Wonder bread.

[AndyCohen]

Sept 18, 2014 16:40:14 GMT -5 rjamz said:

What is up with all you creamy peanut butter people??? Extra super duper chunky!

I like crunchy on toast or toasted bagel. I think it's just the spread ability I prefer.

[bean47]

Crunchy and no jelly.

[shmoo]

My favorite was 365 brand crunchy (I think it had salt added but no sugar) with strawberry preserves.

Almond butter had to be eaten with raspberry preserves only.