Shoes: cute or no?

[derp]

I really like these, but I feel like the heel is either too tall or chunky or both.
www.modcloth.com/shop/shoes-heels/that-s-so-maven-heel

Wondering what others think - am I right about the heel, or are they cute?

[ilovebed]

If I saw someone else wearing these I would think they were super hip and cool. I couldn't pull them off but I like the style of them and the chunky heel is okay with me.

[house]

I like them.

[aak0517]

Hmm... not my style, but I'm not a hufe loafer type shoe person in general- I bought a pair to try and ended up donating them.

[bimbi284]

I like everything but the heel, and I am not opposed to chunky heels, but that particular shape of heel is pretty bad.

[derp]

That's kind of how I feel, too, bimbi. I wish I could change the heel even just a little, because I love the rest.

[Deleted]

Nms.  I think I'd need to see them on with an outfit to really judge though.  

[callmehales]

that heel is HEINOUS. like a nerdy witch trying to get in with the cool witches.

[mrspost08]

NMS

[lexxasaurus]

Cute until you get to the heel and something about it is just... wrong.

[bethaboo]

I'm not a fan.

[mrsukyankee]

Chunky heels are the thing this year (at least in London).

[derp]

Sept 22, 2014 21:33:27 GMT -5 @blueyes623 said:

Nms.  I think I'd need to see them on with an outfit to really judge though.  

I was thinking skinny jeans and a cardigan like this:

www.modcloth.com/shop/sweaters/vanilla-bean-dream-cardigan

Callme, I like your straightforwardness, lol. That's what I was afraid of.

[LoveBug]

I'm not a fan of them.

[sa]

Not a fan....I actually don't mind the heel itself, it's the rest of the shoe I don't care for. I don't like the toe box -- too round or something. Combined with the chunky heel...it's not good. I'd pass.

[callmehales]

with the cardigan you posted you could do a wedge ankle bootie or an oxford type shoe!

[derp]

Ok thanks all! You confirmed my instinct. I'll skip these.

[derp]

Can anyone help me find a pair of nice color blocked oxford/brogue type shoes that might work better? I like the look. I found these that I really like, but they're a bit spendy for me right now.

[mrsg123]

They are too costumey for me.