If you had to have a reclining sofa...

[rubytue]

And it had to be beige-ish leather. Are either of these almost tolerable?

(Will be in 2 posts bc I still use the unsupported app that only does one pic at a time)

Sofa A:

Attachments:

[rubytue]

Sofa B:

Attachments:

[rubytue]

And just for context, this is what I'm replacing. I love the look, but it's not working for us when we want to be slugs.

Attachments:

[VillainV]

They're both okay, I have no major objections to either, but I also think that sofas should be comfy, so there's that. (Edited for clarity).

[steph96]

It looks like the arms on B would be too low.

[rubytue]

I think I'm down to those two. They don't look as poofy as most recliners. I think I would be ok with either.

B is about 600 cheaper (after delivery and tax)

I tried to ask H. He said "it's our couch! Twice!" Lol But then initiated he wanted a test sit in both.

[aurora]

I like A better.

[shopgirl07]

Sorry, I think they're dreadful. They have the overstuffed 80s look.

[scout8]

I think A is better, but why do you have to have a sofa recliner? Is the some reason a sofa with a chaise or a sofa with big ottoman wouldn't work?

[noodleoo]

Am I crazy, because all 3 sofas look the same to me. I'd go with whichever is more comfortable.

[babsbunny]

Sept 5, 2015 8:45:35 GMT -5 scout8 said:

I think A is better, but why do you have to have a sofa recliner? Is the some reason a sofa with a chaise or a sofa with big ottoman wouldn't work?

Because reclining sofas are AWESOME!  DH and I love ours.  The recline is different than just putting your feet up - it kind of cups your back as it moves your whole body.

[rubytue]

Sept 5, 2015 9:13:04 GMT -5 noodleoo said:

Am I crazy, because all 3 sofas look the same to me. I'd go with whichever is more comfortable.

No. H said the same thing. Which means I'm on the right track, I think . Subtle differences. A is more straight lines. B is a bit poofier and more cream (but $600 cheaper). And our current couch has legs without recliner function. And no extra cushion on the arms. Which is why there are 7 pillows on the couch - for me to move around for support in places the couch doesn't have it. *sigh*

[Deleted]

Of those options I prefer sofa B

[livinitup]

I prefer whichever is the cheaper one because they look the same, and I like to keep $600 when I have a choice. I might buy the one that is more comfy but they look like they woud both be comfy.

[rubytue]

Well, we went shopping today. Neither of those worked out, but we are seriously considering this one.

Attachments:

[Redpoppy]

My main concern outside of comfort would be how many seams are on the leather since I feel like those wear down. B had too many seams.