Help choosing between two bags?

[mammina]

Newish to the board and was hoping to get opinions on the following two bags. They are just about the same size and I intend to use the crossbody strap as well as the handle. Which one do you prefer (shape, hardware, handle, whatever)... LEFT or RIGHT?
Thanks!

[LoveBug]

I think I prefer the left since it has some structure to sit up on its own.

[Deleted]

The one on the right (silver hardware). But that bag has been on my "want list" for a while

[kellsbelles]

I don't know if it's just a bad picture but the one on the right looks almost weathered making the left look shiny and new. That being said I prefer the left.

[bimbi284]

Left

[cransplash]

Left

[jchokie79]

I like the one on the left better.

[veruca5839]

Left

[aak0517]

I have the one on the right and love it but the strap on it(at least mine) makes wearing it as a crossbody a little awkward (it's a little short) but otherwise it's a great bag and i love it. I almost got the one on the left at the rack, and went with a slightly different MBMJ one that i could wear as a crossbody. As far as harware, I prefer gold so that gets my vote and between the two.

In this case from the ones you posted, I'd go with either, but the gold hardware would sell me.

[xokell2]

Left!

[joyhart02]

Left for sure. I like that structure better, the one on the right I feel like things get lost in the bottom.

[Deleted]

Another vote for the one on the left.

[gringachef]

Left- I much prefer the gold hardware

[mammina]

Thanks so much! Looks like we have a winner, left satchel it is!
I honestly wasn't able to decide and now I think I may get the one below as well to satisfy my love of that front pleat! (25% off lots of MBMJ bags at Saks, Nordstrom and more)

[aqualuv]

I have the right, but a older version since mine doesn't have the pleating/detail on the front. I really like MBMJ Hillier. I have it in brown and black.

[mrspost08]

I like the left one best.

[brewalexa]

Left. For sure.

[cobber06]

Left- I love the gold hardware.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk