UPDATED mascara for thin eyelashes

[agnes]

****UPDATE: I just bought the orange one this weekend and I'm waiting for the Sephora one to come any day.

I'm wearing the orange one today...Hate it. It feels clumpier than the purple one. It does nothing for my eyelashes but make them look like spider legs.****



A long time ago I had a mascara post on the old MM. The most recommended mascara was for Cavergirl in the purple tube (I think lash blast or something). But I can't remember which one exactly. Well, I don't like it all that much. I feel like it clumps up my eye lashes instead of making them feel/look fuller.

Any other recommendations? Preferably not waterproof and not super expensive.

[cjeanette]

I hate the purple tube but love the orange

Sent from my SPH-D700 using proboards

[Deleted]

The orange tube is great.

[agnes]

I'll have to try both of these. Thanks!

[agnes]

Update above.

[rosetyler]

I love Urban Decay Lush Lash. I have thin eyelashes, and it makes them look thick and lush, not clumpy and spidery. I need thickening more than length (though I'll take both if I can get it).

[dexteroni]

I love Benefit's They're Real. I don't know what your criteria is for super expensive; the regular size is $23 but it also comes in a smaller tube for $10.

[evans]

I really like Buxom mascara. It's great and Sephora often has a mini for $10. I don't mind getting them because you're supposed to change every few months anyway.

[Deleted]

Nov 19, 2012 18:52:27 GMT -5 dexteroni said:

I love Benefit's They're Real. I don't know what your criteria is for su

per expensive; the regular size is $23 but it also comes in a smaller tube for $10.

I hate this one. It is clumpy on me. I love the Benefit Bad Gal lash. Same prices.

[agnes]

I am going to have to try all of these! lol

dexter, the cheaper the better, but I don't have a problem spending 20-30 bucks.

[dexteroni]

Nov 19, 2012 21:00:26 GMT -5 @kcpokergal said:

Nov 19, 2012 18:52:27 GMT -5 dexteroni said:

I love Benefit's They're Real. I don't know what your criteria is for su

per expensive; the regular size is $23 but it also comes in a smaller tube for $10.

I hate this one. It is clumpy on me. I love the Benefit Bad Gal lash. Same prices.

I like both of these bit I think They're Real gives more thickness. But Bad Gal Lash also comes in the small-sized tube. I love those little tubes.

[rosetyler]

Nov 19, 2012 21:00:26 GMT -5 @kcpokergal said:

Nov 19, 2012 18:52:27 GMT -5 dexteroni said:

I love Benefit's They're Real. I don't know what your criteria is for su

per expensive; the regular size is $23 but it also comes in a smaller tube for $10.

I hate this one. It is clumpy on me. I love the Benefit Bad Gal lash. Same prices.

I have They're Real, and for thinner lashes, it's not my favorite. It does make them look longer, but I don't get the "pow" impact of a thickening mascara. Also, it clumps for me, too.

[KaraOrNot]

I love Tarte's mascara. I tried it in Sephora's mascara sampler last year and loved it.

www.sephora.com/gifted-amazonian-clay-smart-mascara-P286101?skuId=1328913

I did really like the sampler set. It let me try a bunch of different mascaras and determine which worked best. Plus, the samples were large enough that they lasted all year. To be MM, it went on sale after Christmas last year!

www.sephora.com/lash-stash-P376731?skuId=1453919