I am trying this tomorrow for my holiday party. I will add a little more gold shimmer to it. It seems easy she uses toasted, buck and the two on the end for a smokey look. Here's the video you can watch later.
I love gold for the holidays! Highlight brow area with Virgin. Apply Half Baked all over lid. Then apply Smog on your lid. Then blend Darkhorse into your crease. Finish with a dark brown or black eyeliner and lots of mascara.
This is kinda the overall look (but without the freakishly groomed brows):
Keeping in mind that my "dramatic" is probably way less intense than others, I love this combo and it doesn't look like I'm playing dress up:
Virgin as brow highlighter and inner corners Toasted (blend with Sin if you need to lighten) all over lid Hustle in crease/outer corners Half Baked in center of lid, above irises
I need to find a new everyday look. Right now I do Virgin across the eyelid and browbone, Sin across the lid, Toasted on the outer half of the lid, and Creep in the outer corner. I'm starting to hit the bottom of the tin on Virgin and Toasted
The Tiffany D blog I linked to has a lot of good tutorials.