I'm not a fan of cellular shades. I have the light blocking version of the second one and really like it.
I really like them, actually. I have a top down bottom up white set in my bedroom, I love how they insulate and filter the light. I'm not sure about the color of these, but I love that they are cordless and the kids can open them. We don't have anything with cords now so it would be nice to stay that way with a new babe otw. I love the look of the bamboo more, but the cord thing is getting me. hmmm.