PW today. I'd like opinions, please

[tiramisu]

I've decided to rent a fancy dress for my birthday celebration.  Because I want to look and feel fabulous and because I'm resisting thinking of birthdays as anything negative.  So, which dress?  FTR, I'm pear-shaped but with broad shoulders, though my mom likes to say I'm an hourglass.  My waist is my thinnest point.

1. www.renttherunway.com/shop/designers/nicolemiller_dresses/workwhatyougotdress

2. www.renttherunway.com/shop/designers/badgleymischka_dresses/fifthavenueshowstopperdress

3. www.renttherunway.com/shop/designers/badgleymischka_dresses/midnightglamourdress

4. www.renttherunway.com/shop/designers/theia_dresses/dippedvanilladress


ETA: I can rent a second dress for only $25, so you can pick your two favorite.

[captainmel]

It won't let me vote. Waahhh....

I like 2 or 3. I think the first one is a little short and I don't love the last one. I would pick from the other two based on what accessories and shoes you have already.

[tiramisu]

I have black leather heels, brown suede heels, silver & gold strappy heels, deep red patent leather heels...LOTS of shoes.

My first inclination is towards #2, but red looks great on me and I'm not a huge pink fan. I'm 5'6", so I'm thinking even the ones that look short might be a little longer, based on the other renter photos. I tend to prefer knee-length, but since I'm going to be hitting a club or two, I figure a little shorter will be okay.

[captainmel]

I feel like number two is just barely pink.

The red dress is gorgeous though and if you like the red I'm sure you'd look amazing in it. I also love that you have so many shoe choices.

[starrieskies]

I really kind of gravitated towared 2 or 3... But they were all beautiful!

Also, at this point this has to be one of the least helpful polls evah... (3 votes, each for a different dress)

[tiramisu]

Aug 23, 2013 18:51:28 GMT -5 starrieskies said:

I really kind of gravitated towared 2 or 3... But they were all beautiful!

Also, at this point this has to be one of the least helpful polls evah... (3 votes, each for a different dress)

Seriously!

Umm...if it helps, my coloring is light, with golden undertones.

[Chirp]

I actually like #1 the most. If you're comfortable with the length, go for it.

[tiramisu]

Sorry, I removed and re-did the poll. You can choose two options, because I can rent a second dress for only $25. I'm leaning towards the red dress and either the pink or the navy sequins.

[tiramisu]

All of you creepers looking and not voting!

[Deleted]

I don't like #2 at all I think it is too much making it look,,,,,,ummmmm cheap

I love the red or gold

[cuddlyevil]

I like #1 & #2. I do like the red better though.

[wrathofkuus]

I like #4.

[motzie]

I think that red would look amazing on you. It doesn't feel as fancy as the others, but I think you would kill it. That or #2 if you want more glitz.

[Kore]

I love 2 & 3. All are beautiful, though!

[partiallysunny]

I like 3 best (blue sequins), but 1 (the red) is sexy!

[bullygirl979]

I think 2 would accentuate your waist so if that is a good feature on you, go for it!

[margarita]

I love # 3! That's the one I voted for.

I don't think you can go wrong though. They're all very pretty.

[Muddled]

Did you decide?

[tiramisu]

I ended up renting #1 and #2. I'll try them both on when they arrive and decide which one looks better on. Thanks everyone for your opinions!

[gault]

WE WANT PIP'S when you get them!