Which pendant lantern? (LIP)

[simpsongal]

We need to replace the lantern hanging in the center of our front porch (2-story height w/4 columns). Our house is a "southern colonial" - it's white w/orangy brick on the bottom & black shutters. I just can't decide. I suppose we should go w/something black. There's a lamp post out front that needs a new fixture too - I guess they should match?

Here are some reasonably priced ones I found on Wayfair- feel free to PIP or link a different recommendation (under $350 please!)

www.wayfair.com/Savoy-House-Castlemain-Outdoor-Hanging-Lantern-in-Black-Gold-SOY1605.html

www.wayfair.com/Hinkley-Lighting-Trafalgar-Outdoor-Hanging-Lantern-in-Museum-Black-Energy-Star-Optional-HD2583.html

www.wayfair.com/Capital-Lighting-Inman-Park-Three-Light-Outdoor-Hanging-Lantern-in-Old-Bronze-9386OB-CPG1434.html

www.wayfair.com/Maxim-Lighting-Carriage-House-VX-28-Outdoor-Hanging-Lantern-40428WGOB-MXL3328.html

www.wayfair.com/Quoizel-31-Devon-Outdoor-Hanging-Lantern-in-Imperial-Bronze-DE1490IB-QZ1707.html

TIA!

[ssmjlm]

Do you have a pic of the front of your house? I could pic one, but I have no idea the style of your home and not all of these read the same to me style wise.

Although honestly I only like 1 & 2.

[simpsongal]

Here's a pic w/the old lantern.

[ssmjlm]

Yeah I still say 1 or 2 with the colonial style. I would definitely do the larger size if you go with 1.

Also I gues you have to decide if you want the light shining up or down. 1 has the lights on the base and 2 has the lights on the top.

[munkii]

I like #2. Number 1 isn't bad, but the glass feels wrong. Here is one similar to #1 but with bubble glass:
www.colonial-lighting.com/search_individual_result.asp?current=367126&page=1

Here is another that is decent:
www.colonial-lighting.com/search_individual_result.asp?current=426518&page=1

[McGavin]

I like the first you posted but I really like the second one that munkii posted.

[magdala9]

I like #2 also.

[mayflowers22]

I like #1!

[FoxInFiji]

I like the Hinkley and Capital lighting options (both yours and munkii's Capital ones) the best. Both are very good brands quality wise as well. So is our Quoizel chandelier. I don't know about the other two.