So I ended up getting the fabric above, in the hot pink (with navy). I'll make a pillow case dress and pair it with some navy and white striped leggings she already has. I bought extra fabric so I can make a scarf for myself, and some quick little headbands for my nieces.
starrieskies I will do lots of PIPs. I ordered some really cute props on Amazon. I also got eye patches and temporary tattoos of ships and mermaids so everyone can get really into it.