Eyeliner Rec?

[martini]

I am looking for a new eyeliner to try.  I previously used and liked Mary Kay black eyeliner, but have been trying to use more cruelty free/paraben free products lately. Any you would recommend? Thanks!

[aak0517]

I've always really liked MACs black eyeliner in "Engraved". I use a liquid on my winged liner but this for the lower lashes.

[lexxasaurus]

Urban Decay has Perversion eyeliner in every form (gel, liquid, pencil) and they are CF - though their parent company is not.

[irishbride2]

I have no clue if they are CF or not but I'm obsessed with Marc Jacob highliners.

[majick143]

I just picked up another Bobbi Brown Long Wear eye pencil and they're a cruelty free brand. I also like NARS liners but the one I have now is feeling dry on my skin for some reason.

[bimbi284]

I love love love my Tarte amazonian clay liners. Aside from that, I use UD liners.

[steph196]

I love Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner.

[IIOY]

I'm a die-hard black gel fan, but can you all say why you love your pencils? I'd be interested in branching out a bit for fun.

I do have a NYX slide-on pencil that I adore. It goes on so smoothly and it lasts forever. I use that when I don't feel like dealing with the fussiness of gel and want a quicker eye.

[browneyedhunni85]

I recently started using Urban Decay 24/7. It's really the only thing I've tried that's still on at the end of the day. I bought the travel sized 4 pack that had the perversion which is black and a dark brown.

[pooh8402]

another UD 24/7 fan. I have several of their liners, including perversion in the pencil.

[Deleted]

This is my absolute favorite liner for top lid and winged liner. 
www.sephora.com/tightline-cake-eye-liner-P285323?skuId=1323203

I got a sample of the UD and it's fabulous on the waterline.  
www.sephora.com/24-7-glide-on-eye-pencil-P133707?skuId=1499078

[peach]

I don't know if it's cruelty free but the Kat Von d tattoo liner is amazing!

[love1999]

I love the Ulta Automatic Eyeliners. They stay put and I normally buy them when they have them on sale for $1 a few times a year.

[MauMau]

Stila Automatic liners or Urban Decay.

[315]

I was given a recommendation to try these: www.tarinatarantino.com/shop/pc/viewPrd.asp?idproduct=13506
They get rave reviews inc from Temptalia.

[Deleted]

Bobbi Brown if you want gel or Chanel if you want self-sharpening pencil.

[secretlyevil]

UD 24/7 are hit or miss for me. NYX SO/GOs are great, except black. Stila is good, the burgundy and I don't mix. I really like Mally's eye liners.