I only have one pair, a light tan. Since Sperrys don't fit my foot right :-( I'm thinking of getting another pair of Toms to wear this summer. What color do you think is most versatile with things? What do you have?
I don't have Toms, but I feel like Navy is my go to color. It goes well with jeans and just about any colored shirt I would wear. For spring and summer, I love navy & pink together, or navy & yellow, navy & mint, etc...
I have black, gray, red, and a new tan/pinkish/plaid pair that I haven't worn much yet.
I wear black and gray most often.
Have you tried the Angelfish style of Sperry's? My feet don't fit right in the regular Sperry's with the longer top/front, but the Angelfish style has a shorter front that works better for my feet.
I went to Nordstrom last spring and tried on all the Sperrys they carry. None worked. That's when I went with the Toms then. I'll try again this year because I really want them to work but I'm not hopeful.
My black crochet are my favorite for summer. I also have charcoal canvas, red canvas, purple corduroy, black with rainbow glitter thread, burlap, and brown with gold thread. Way too many, but I love my Toms.
The ones I wear the most are grey crochet in the warmer weather and a dark grey wool with a fuzzy inside during the winter. I also really love the Toms ballet flats. My favorites are a red with white polka dots and a brown/tan leopard.
I get most of them from Zulily or Nordstrom Rack, or Toms directly if they're having a really good sale.
I have black herringbone pair that I love. I had a pair of ash canvas but they wore out in one summer so not sure I'll buy them again. If I were to buy another pair I'd probably buy a navy.
I do love my Sperrys so it sucks they don't work for you