I would do it. I ended up paying a ridiculous price for pillow cases on eBay that matched a flat and fitted sheet that I had gotten at some discount store. It was still an okay deal and I loved that bedding.
How long ago did you get them? PIP and I can look in my Homegoods next time I go. Put everyone you know across the country on blast and maybe you will find them without the markup.
I just went ahead and bought them. For an extra $35 it's not really worth moaning over, right?
Nope, otherwise you might miss out and then be searching the internet several years later moaning about not having forked over the extra cash at the time! (Ask me how I know)