Chloe "Marcie" or YSL "Muse"???

[bowlica]

So I'm going to get a bag and initially was looking for a new black bag. I went into Nordstrom and was led to the YSL section. I fell in love with the red large Muse. So I thought I should think about it and in the meantime have been browsing the Internet and now I think I really like the Chloe Marcie ( small with straps) in the nut color. I haven't seen the Chloe in person as our Nordstrom didn't have any in store but that they could order it. These are two totally different bags but I wanted to get opinions from people who may have experiences with either. If I do decide to go with Chloe I'm going to kick myself because it was in the anniversary sale. I believe mavjen got it! Also which do you think is more of a classic. TIA!!!

Marcie:
shop.nordstrom.com/s/chloe-marcie-small-calfskin-satchel/3186057?origin=keywordsearch&contextualcategoryid=0&fashionColor=&resultback=2274

Muse in black:
shop.nordstrom.com/S/yves-saint-laurent-muse-large-leather-dome-satchel/3158746?origin=related-3158746-0-0-1-1

Muse in red:
leather-dome-satchel/3158746?origin=related-3158746-0-0-1-1
shop.nordstrom.com/s/yves-saint-laurent-muse-large-leather-dome-satchel/3260418?origin=keywordsearch&contextualcategoryid=0&fashionColor=&resultback=1204

[anaps28]

I happen to love both bags. I tried on the Marcie about a month ago and fell in love with it. I love that it can be either on your shoulder or cross body. The Muse holds a ton but I'm partial to the Marcie. My vote is Marcie

[Étoile]

I have the Muse and love it. I really love the look of Chloé bags but find them soooo heavy to begin with, that filling them would make them beyond heavy. I don't own any large Chloé bags, just clutches, so I can't comment on the Marcie.

[mrsee]

I too, prefer the Marcie....it's a gorgeous bag!

[shopgirl07]

I prefer the Muse. I also think it's easier access when you need to reach in and grab stuff.

[maucat]

I like the look of the Muse better. Especially that red!

[karebear304]

I like the look of the Marcie better because I'm usually in more casual clothes. The Muse wouldn't fit as well in my personal wardrobe, but if you wear a lot of pencil skirts, dresses, etc. to work it would look great.

ETA: Forgot to answer your last question. If I was strictly picking on which bag was more "classic" I'd go Muse in black.