I don't care if everyone is burned out on baby names.

[DarcyLongfellow]

Obviously, Abigail is the superior choice ;-)

[zeewifeandmama]

I really like Abigail

[cincodemayo]

I really like Alice and think it fits well with your DD's name.

What about Brooke? Bridget? Audrey?

[Yankees21]

May 25, 2016 10:31:47 GMT -5 @this said:

May 25, 2016 10:29:06 GMT -5 oceanspray said:

I love Alice but you also said no name ending in a vowel? Or did you mean one that's pronounced?

Yes, I should have clarified. Nothing that ends in "uh." (Ella, Nora, Theodosia, etc lol)

Lol! So no Eliza?

I think Elizabeth is beautiful and goes well with Lucy!

[countthestars]

I LOVE MOLLY SO MUCH.

[DarcyLongfellow]

I don't think you can go wrong with Elizabeth. So many great nicknames!

I also liked (and they seem similar to your tastes):

Lillian
Margaret
Isabelle/Isobel

I also liked a couple that DH hated:
Ruth
Irene

[h]

I have an Alexander and adore it, so that gets my boy vote. But I love Benjamin, too.

I really like Alice and Elizabeth for a girl (Jane was our girl name, but since your H shot it down...). Or maybe:

Anne
Annabel
Margaret (nn Meg or Maggie)
Rebecca (nn Becca)
Elaine
Caroline
Camille (nn Millie)
Audrey
Maren


Eta -- Strike Becca and Millie. I am not following the rules!

[nessness]

I like Alice and I don't really get what you mean by "trying too hard." It's classic and goes well with your DD's name.

[badtzmaru22]

Adrienne
Beatrix
Celeste
Daphne


Good thing I'm not nearly fertile or young enough to be a Duggar. I don't have an E name. And my F name is Fiona, which doesn't meet your criteria.

[Deleted]

May 25, 2016 10:27:10 GMT -5 @this said:

-Molly (isn't this a drug now??)

[ilikedonuts]

I love Alice and Molly.

I had wanted to name DD2 Molly but then I remembered its my IL's dog's name lol

[Deleted]

DD is Lucy Maidenname Lastname.

Requirements:
-nothing that ends in a vowel sound
-nothing that starts with a P
-nothing that has any double Ls

Names I like but can't use:
-Claire (H shot down)
-Jane (H shot down)
-Piper (not with our last name)
-Eleanor nn Nora (not the nn with our last name)
-Ellen (not with our last name)
-Grace (too churchy)
-Katherine nn Kate (um, it's my name but I would use it if it wasn't LOL)

Names I'm considering:
-Elizabeth (H says it's too fancy compared to Lucy lol)
-Alice (trying too hard?)
-Abigail (meh?)
-Molly (isn't this a drug now??) - this is my issue. I want to name this kid Margaret nn Mollie and H is all DRUG CULTURE. BUT I heard the cool kids are snorting cacao these days so Molly is passe. 

I love Alice and Elizabeth. What about Elise, Laurel, Vivian, Violet, Blythe, Beatrice, Charlotte, Hazel 

Read more: pandce.proboards.com/thread/532972/care-burned-out-baby-names#ixzz49gNbbL6x

[Noblegirl]

Elise
Fallon
Helen
Beatrice
Caroline
Emmaline
Harper
Hazel
Scarlett
Rachael

[Koala]

If you like Alexander for a boy, why not go Alexandra (nn Alex) for a girl?

Out of your list, I like Molly.

Others:
Emily
Avery

[Ashley&Scott]

Aubrey
Anne
Avery
Eden
Elise
Ellis
Evelyn
Hazel
Juliet
Madelyn
Violet

[h]

May 25, 2016 10:39:34 GMT -5 @this said:

I LOVE Anne, but feel like I would always need to clarify, "THAT'S ANNE WITH AN E."

Anne is awesome and very underused as a first name these days. Anne is a classic and relatively common spelling, and I don't think specifying with an e would be that big a deal. I have a common first name with at least two common spellings (plus several alternative spellings), and having to specify which spelling I use has never bothered me.

[broadsheet]

Caroline
Audrey
Catherine
Cecily
Jane


ETA: reading fail. Strike Jane!

[patbutcher]

I like Alice the best. What do you mean by trying too hard?

[glitzy07]

HAZEL.

I'm still mad I didn't get to use it. lol

[froggy76]

My name is Elizabeth and I've always loved it. I go by Liz. It's strong and professional. I don't know why people always try to get creative with nicknames for Elizabeth.

I don't think it's too fancy to go with Lucy.

[Deleted]

My first is Lucille (but we call her Lucy) and we also have an Italian last name.

Our second we were so sure would be a boy and we were going to name him Alexander. But then surprise it was a girl so we went through a bunch of names and ended up feminizing it and naming her Alexandra and calling her Lexi. . It ends in a vowel though.

Other names we had considered (a lot end with a vowel just because a lot of girls names do)
Vivian
Emilia (nn Emmy)
Adriana
Evelyn (nn Evie)
Helen or Helena
Caroline
Juliette
Alexis

[countthestars]

Jocelyn?

ETA: nn Josie (heart)

[cincodemayo]

Ooh I do like Alexandra nn Alex!

[Deleted]

May 25, 2016 10:43:48 GMT -5 @this said:

I've gotten three FB friend requests since I posted this. LOL  :-#

[Deleted]

I think something ending with an N sound would be good.

Megan (or one of it's varieties)
Maren
Erin

[Deleted]

You could name her Amy??  

[Deleted]

Look at that. I don't even have kids, and two people already dig my suggestions.

AREN'T YOU GLAD I AM UPPING THE COOL QUOTIENT AROUND HERE?

[chickens987]

Juliet, duh.

@starry

[anna7602]

Why is Alice trying too hard? I really like it, along with names like Helen and Louise that are classic, but not as popular these days.

Otherwise, my tastes fall squarely in "ends in -a" territory. Lydia is what I am convinced we should have named DS had he been a girl. (Although we let DD pick the girl's name from my list of five and she did not choose Lydia.)

[shelbyann]

I love Anne and I think it would be beautiful with your name combo and also goes well with Lucy.

I see what you mean about Alice being a little theme-y with Lucy. It's a lovely name though. I gave both my kids very Scandinavian names so I'm not one to judge though.

I like Abigail. Elizabeth is a bit of a mouthful with your MN LN.