Shoe size ? - Rothy's and Chuck Taylor - oops wrong board!

[pierogigirl]

I am a size 9.5 (very rarely a 10).  For Rothy's round toe, if you are a half size, do you go up? Chuck Taylor Shoreline only comes in women's full size - I was going to go up to a 10, unless they run really big.  The reviews were not helpful. I have regular Chucks, but they are a men's size.


EDIT- Sorry! Wrong board.

[wawa]

But I have opinions on this!!

I had to size up my chucks because they ran narrow. But they are for sure too long as a result. Rothys I would not size up a round toe.

[StrawberryBlondie]

I am ALWAYS a size 8. Always. Like all my life, literally every shoe that's been recommended to me to size up a half size, if I've done it, I've had to exchange for my normal size.

Then came Rothy's. I have to size up a half size. I have the round toe and the sneaker and had to do so in both.

I wear my normal size in chucks.

ETA: I originally got my normal size in Rothy's (see paragraph 1). They were both too short and too narrow.

[duff]

I go up a half size in round toe Rothy's and a full size in points. I surprisingly don't have any Chucks, so no idea there.

[beetea]

I'm also a 9.5 (occasional 10) - I've sized up in round toe Rothy's and Chucks.

[katieinthecity]

I'm usually a 9, rarely I'll go to a 9.5. My roundtoe Rothy's are 9.5, and I probably could've gone to a 10, TBH.

[nessness]

I'm usually a 9, and had to size up to 9.5 in round-toe Rothy's.

[cherry1111]

So here is my Rothys info:

Normal shoe size - 8 - 8.5
Converse Shorelines - 8
Rothys sneakers - 8.5
Rothys flats - 9
Rothys points - 9.5
Rothys loafers - 9.5

You don’t want Rothys to feel tight at all. It took several exchanges to figure out my correct size. If you need a referral code let me know!

[smock]

Hi, foot twin! I pretty much wear 9.5 in shoes without socks, and 10 in heels or shoes with socks. I have round toe Rothy's in 9.5 and Chuck Taylor Shorelines in 10. Both fit great. (and I wear the shorelines without socks)

[LoveTrains]

I wear a 7 and my round toe 7 rothys are way too tight. I have a wide foot.

[msmerymac]

I have a wide foot, usually a 7, but I size up to 7.5 in heels and a few other shoes. I wear the 7.5 in round tow Rothys, but would also fit in an 8, and I NEED an 8 for any of their other styles.

One issue now is that Rothys has made their insole a bit thicker, so my newer 7.5 flats are a bit more snug than the older ones. When you try them on, try them both with and without the insole. If they feel better, room-wise, without the insole, then exchange them for the next half size up.