Goldbelly recs

[7costanza]

I have $150 to spend at Goldbelly, any recommendations? No allergies or food restrictions to take into consideration.

[mambo123]

Antico is my fave pizza place in ATL, and it reheats nicely. We’ve purchased from Gold Belly a few times just for their pizza.

[underwaterrhymes]

Do you like seafood?

Highly HIGHLY recommend the crab bombs from Jerry’s.

www.goldbelly.com/jerrys-seafood/the-crab-bombs-10-oz-size

[Susie]

My BFF sent me dungeoness crab and chowder for my 40th bday from Pikes Place Fish Market via Goldbelly, and it was really good.

[tacokick]

Russ and Daughters

Ess-a-bagel

We got Zahav but the side dishes were really skimpy. I even weighed them and they were about half what they were supposed to be. They were very dismissive when I contacted them. They also sent me a different dessert than what I ordered and it arrived melted.

[isabel]

I’ve been really wanting to try Malai ice cream. It’s owned by an Indian woman and the flavors reflect her childhood and all the spices in Indian cuisine.

[dearprudence]

We also mostly use Goldbelly for bagels (Ess-a-bagel, Russ and Daughters, Pick a bagel). Sometimes Black and Whites (William Greenberg, Russ and Daughters, Orwashers) or cannoli from Ferraras.

[dirtyred]

The fancy truffles are fantastic. There's a sampler I got for my dad at $100 and he raved about them for weeks.

[brooklyn]

Always ess-a-bagel

[7costanza]

Jun 13, 2022 17:31:08 GMT -5 Susie said:

My BFF sent me dungeoness crab and chowder for my 40th bday from Pikes Place Fish Market via Goldbelly, and it was really good.

I actually live in Seattle but haven’t tried this, I’m going to get it next time I’m downtown!

[7costanza]

Thanks everybody! Lots of recs for ess-a-bagel so I’ll likely try that!

[7costanza]

Jun 13, 2022 17:06:44 GMT -5 underwaterrhymes said:

Do you like seafood?

Highly HIGHLY recommend the crab bombs from Jerry’s.

www.goldbelly.com/jerrys-seafood/the-crab-bombs-10-oz-size

I do and those look really good!

[orval]

These are my favorite thing on Goldbelly! They are huge!
www.goldbelly.com/nicks-kitchen/23238-pork-tenderloin-sandwich-8-pack?ref=search&search_id=67584870

[formerlyak]

If you like BBQ, we’ve ordered Franklin and also Salt Lick. Both are yummy!

[mrsslocombe]

Jun 13, 2022 18:08:07 GMT -5 isabel said:

I’ve been really wanting to try Malai ice cream. It’s owned by an Indian woman and the flavors reflect her childhood and all the spices in Indian cuisine.

Malai is really, really good. The chai flavor is perfect. If they have the ice cream sandwiches on Goldbelly those are amazing too.

[cville]

All my recs are for delicious vegetarian stuff, but if you like cheesecake, the Juniors and the Elles Belles cheesecakes both are good and traveled well. The Elis was so so.

Unsure why so many people send me cheesecakes, but now l'm an expert.

[ksun]

I got the JFK wedding cake from Montilio's for my birthday this year. It was the most perfect cake I've ever had.