Which would you/ did you get?

[belichick]

I am treating myself this weekend and was all set to buy the Urban Decay Vice Palette when I came across the two Tarte Holiday collections-

www.ulta.com/ulta/browse/productDetail.jsp?skuId=2250912&productId=xlsImpprod4690163&navAction=push&navCount=1

www.sephora.com/carried-away-collector-s-set-P376087

The Tarte sets look like such incredible deals but I don't have much experience with their shadows. Can anyone tell me how they compare with UD? Of the three which would you get?

Thanks!

[bimbi284]

I want that big one from sephora SO BADLY!! Its on my X-mas list :-).

I've been told that tarte shadows are really good. I saw the vice palette too, but I think I liked the variety of colors (and products!) in the Tarte Carried Away set better.

[billysgirl07]

I have the Tarte Call of the Wild (I think that's what it is called) palette. I like the shadows as much or more as either of my UD Naked palettes.

The Tarted Carried Away set (as well as the set of the lip surgance glosses) is on the UPS truck as we speak to be delivered to my house. I can't wait!

[Deleted]

I think for the extra $4 I'd get the kit offered by Sephora. While I may not use all the eyeshadows, I currently use the powder, blush and am obsessed with the mascara. I'm a lip gloss junkie. So the glosses would definitely get used.

[SKP82]

I have a palette by Tarte and I loooove it! But, I haven't used UD, so I don't know how they compare.

[belichick]

Thanks! I think I'm leaning towards the Tarte Carried Away, it seems like so much more for the money than the UD palette.

Billysgirl - please let us know what you think when it arrives :-)

[billysgirl07]

Well, I haven't tried any of the shadows yet in this palette but I think that the Tarte is the way to go! The bag it comes in is really nice - and there is a spot for the shadow palette to be stashed, which is convenient for travel. Here are some photos:








(glosses: Jana, Mer, Ali, Nuria)


(glosses: Heath, Casey, Anna, Mel)




(blush: Adventurous)

[billysgirl07]

Oh, and I got the set of lipsurgance glosses and 2 of the 5 are broken...guess that one will be going back for an exchange!

[belichick]

Oct 1, 2012 21:24:57 GMT -5 billysgirl07 said:

Well, I haven't tried any of the shadows yet in this palette but I think that the Tarte is the way to go! The bag it comes in is really nice - and there is a spot for the shadow palette to be stashed, which is convenient for travel. Here are some photos:








(glosses: Jana, Mer, Ali, Nuria)


(glosses: Heath, Casey, Anna, Mel)




(blush: Adventurous)

The glosses look great, thanks for sharing. I'll be ordering in the next day or two ;D

Sorry your other set is broken, I hope they can get you a new set fast.