I'm a sometimes lurker here and thought I'd ask for help from those bored by the debate...
I just bought this dress: www.modcloth.com/shop/dresses/lacking-nothing-dress and assuming I like it on, I'll need help picking out shoes. I was told I "look like a dead horse walking" in heels once (ouch, but probably accurate) so I can't handle really high heels.
A basic black pump or pump wedge would look great. You could also do a mary jane or t-strap pump or wedge in black.
If you're feeling adventurous, either of the above in a bright color would be fun.
I'd go with silver jewelry.
I am not adventurous... so black is probably best. I just had to google "pump-wedge" haha I didn't know they had a special name!
LOL! I figured I'd be specific. The dress is super cute, FTR. I think it would look cute with a textured nylon, and a pop of color in a clutch, kinda like this: