Help me pick a guest bed/mattress. Choices inside.

[lmdbww]

I am about to order our guest room bed. I have narrowed it down to these 2 choices. Both have excellent ratings, the exact same bed frame (which is exactly what I needed because we need the storage underneath), and they are also both the same price.


www.samsclub.com/sams/12-night-therapy-euro-box-top-spring-mattress-bed-frame-set-full/prod2980315.ip?navAction=push

vs

www.samsclub.com/sams/night-therapy-8-memory-foam-mattress-bed-frame-set-full/prod720803.ip?navAction=push

Thoughts? The first one does have a 10 year limited warranty. Does that seal the deal?

We get guests a handful of times a year, if it matters.

[house]

#1.

[LoveTrains]

Why would you want #2 when #1 is thicker and the same price?
#1.

[lmdbww]

Nov 6, 2012 20:18:10 GMT -5 LoveTrains said:

Why would you want #2 when #1 is thicker and the same price?
#1.

#2 is memory foam and #1 is not (so it's not comparing apples to apples, I guess...)

I do not have a memory foam mattress but it was recommended for me to get one for a guest bed once. That's why it was getting consideration.

[mrs.jacinthe]

Skip the memory foam. Most people don't like them the first couple nights they sleep on them, and assuming your guests are normal, it will make for a miserable couple nights.

From personal experience ... the ILs have one in their guest room (where R and I sleep on separate twin beds, LOL) and it is too hot, too stiff, too high off the floor, too EVERYTHING for me. I'd rather sleep on their living room sofa than spend another night on that thing.

[kaylie]

I'm not a fan of memory foam. It's not plush enough for me.