Whovians!!! 50 anni spoilers inside!

[Mrs. ChanandlerBong]

I'd rather have Donna back (with all her memories) than Rose.

[cuddlyevil]

Aw, I liked Rose. Though I liked her better with 9.

I may need to forward this link on to one of my doctors, he's a whovian though so probably already aware of this.

[nomad100]

Apr 3, 2013 13:14:20 GMT -5 Mrs. ChanandlerBong said:

I'd rather have Donna back (with all her memories) than Rose.

Me too.  While I appreciated the 10/Rose relationship there was just something that made me not love her.  Not like Donna (and her grandfather, loved him too!)

10 will be my favorite Doctor forever but 11 is growing on me now that he is getting a bit less Tigger-like.  He was too bouncy and floppy for me during the Pond episodes. 

I would love to see Canton Delaware show up in another episode.

[midnightrae]

Apr 3, 2013 13:24:55 GMT -5 cuddlyevil said:

Aw, I liked Rose. Though I liked her better with 9.

I may need to forward this link on to one of my doctors, he's a whovian though so probably already aware of this.

I hated 9. I didn't like Rose at first, but she grew on me. Especially her relationship with 10. I liked Donna's grandfather better than Donna. She annoyed the crap out of me. 

[cuddlyevil]

My doc hates 9 too. I think they wrote him the right way to get things going again and to build up the necessity of the Doctor having a companion. 9 had been alone for so long that he lost his connection to the compassionate side of life--if you think through those episodes, it was Rose who got him thinking more about how his decisions affected everything around him. But Tom Baker will always be my favorite Doctor and his was rather condescending and "You're stupid, I'm right" about his companions and those he was helping too. I really don't have a Doctor that I dislike though.