ha. my mom ended up naming me for her sister/aunt/great aunt/great grandmother. and then her sister turned out to be a jerkface. i think i'd take stephanie.
I have an aunt Mary, a grandmother Mary, 2 great grandmother Marys, an actual fuckton of great aunt Marys. Trendy it is not.
BUT! my mom compromised on Stephanie since it is her mom that was Mary, so she held out on picking the middle name WHICH HAS SINCE BECOME TRENDY! And so has my sister's middle name!