Everyone come in, super important

[TrickyBob]

All of those who said mayo on grilled cheese is the best thing EVAH are lying liars who lie! 

It doesn't crisp up as awesome as butter. 






That is all. 


(but I still ate it and enjoyed it, except I had to use a fork)

[missmaddie]

Ick. Not sure how I would feel about that.

[polka]

I hate mayo, so I will take your word for it.

[TrickyBob]

If it would crisp up, it'd be fine. I just don't like squishy bread, even if slightly toasty. I just like the way butter gets crisp and doesn't soak into the bread.

Taste wise? Tastes the same, you wouldn't know it had mayo.

[kcr1972]

It does but you have to do a very light coating of mayo. I am a mayo on grilled cheese convert after reading it here. I hate soggy grilled cheese.

[glitzyglow]

Mayo inside the sandwich with the cheese. Butter on the outside. So good.

[zoidberg]

You didn't use light, did you?

[TrickyBob]

Nope, not light. I'm a purist.

[zoidberg]

I have tried it and it was perfectly crispy and delicious.

And then one time I tried it with light. Tragedy.

[TrickyBob]

Hmm. I have no idea then.

I might need a thicker bread, I used plain old Giant brand white bread.

[zoidberg]

Was your pan hot enough?

[TrickyBob]

I believe so. I don't know, I only used mayo because my butter is hard. lol

[angelaa73]

i gag that you ate your sandwich with a fork.

Rallllllph

[TrickyBob]

Jun 7, 2013 0:18:24 GMT -5 angelaa73 said:

i gag that you ate your sandwich with a fork.

Rallllllph

You're not a fork person, are you? 

I am. If it can be eaten with a fork, I'll use a fork. I picked this up as a kid and never shook it, I don't like greasy fingers. Plus I had to be able to stab pieces of dill pickle with pieces of grilled cheese. Perfect ratios and all.

[messykitchen]

My dad eats everything from burgers to candy bars with a fork. I have never tried to grill mayo.

That is all I have to add LOL.

[TrickyBob]

LOL, to be fair, I eat burgers with my hands (unless they are super messy) and I don't use them on candy bars.

I DO use them on doughnuts and cheese curls. It's easier to stab things than to get messy hands.

[lucky513]

You did it WRONG

[TrickyBob]

Well tell me how to do it RIGHT


Mmmk?

[lucky513]

You have to get the butter in the pan hot but not burning and lightly spread the mayo
Add one slice of bread mayo side up heat until light crisp
I take it off and add more butter
Then the next slice
Heat a little add cheese and the top with the other slice flip a few more times and walllla

If this doesn't make since message me tomorrow I've drank to muck tonight

[TrickyBob]

But those are a lot of steps.

Butter AND mayo?

Pft.

I'll stick to butter.

[snickers]

Yuck, I refuse to even try that!

[Deleted]

Wait wait wait, so you grill the mayonnaise side of the bread? Or does the mayo side face the inside with the cheese. I'm real confused. Mayo on inside sounds fine, mayo on outside, no no no. Butter goes on the outside.

[bonquiqui]

Ick i hate all of these things

[lolly]

You know what's delicious? Take an English muffin, turn it nooks & crannies side out, and make your grilled cheese that way. YWIA.

[Jalapeñomel]

I will say it again, mayo is gross and needs to be left off any and all of my food.

[Kit]

Mayo does not belong on grilled cheese! That is my final answer.

[Jalapeñomel]

Jun 7, 2013 1:48:32 GMT -5 messykitchen said:

My dad eats everything from burgers to candy bars with a fork. I have never tried to grill mayo.

That is all I have to add LOL.

I can't eat with my hands, so I eat everything with utensils (even burgers and chicken wings).

[glitzyglow]

Jun 7, 2013 7:02:07 GMT -5 @juliash said:

Wait wait wait, so you grill the mayonnaise side of the bread? Or does the mayo side face the inside with the cheese. I'm real confused. Mayo on inside sounds fine, mayo on outside, no no no. Butter goes on the outside.

I put my mayo on the inside of the sandwich with the cheese, and then I use butter on the outside. Healthy, no. Delicious, yes. I still remember the first time I had a non-mayo grilled cheese in my childhood. I was at a friend's house and I couldn't figure out wtf was wrong with my sandwich, lol.

[ElizabethBennet]

Mayo is totally not the same as butter.

My H uses canola oil to make his. CANOLA OIL, PEOPLE. I want to cry each time he makes one.