Resort like The Caves in Jamaica?

[vegas]

This is really random, but DH and I are planning another trip similar to our trip last year to The Caves. We'd like to try somewhere else in the Caribbean but we want something like The Caves--great food, small, quiet, exclusive-feeling, and perhaps around the same price (under $600 a night). I just finished my long overdue Caves review on tripadvisor and it reminded me of the amazing trip we had. We could just go back but we'd like to try something new. Has anyone come across or visited a resort that is similar to The Caves? I'd love recommendations.