Whodunnit

[Dumbledork]

Is anyone else watching this hot mess? This is my trashy summer guilty pleasure. I was hoping it'd be a little more like The Mole from years ago, but it's just so over-the-top cheesy and dramatic. It could have been so much better, but it's just awful. I need to know if my guess for the killer is right though!

If you're watching, how do you like it? Any guess on the killer? I'm banking on Melina, the girl with the brown curly hair.

[cabbage10]

My SO and I are watching too. Totally agree with the cheesiness factor. I think it's Dena. She is just so dumb acting and even though she got the last two "scared" cards she isn't getting killed.

I feel like no wonder Don is an ex homicide detective since he never could put any of the clues together. Haha. Even though its such a silly show i plan to stick with it through the summer

[ddi741]

We are enjoying it. I have no idea who the killer is. Is it me or have all these people been on other reality shows before. They all look so familar to me.

[Dumbledork]

I don't recognize anyone, but I know the feeling. I still think the girl on Carrie Diaries looks like a young GG Blair, but I'm apparently the only one.

[mmmomof2]

The cheetah at the end of the last episode had me LOL. It amuses me that they keep talking about how scared they are and how sad they are that so and so died. The editors must have had to edit out the part where they say "oh yeah, this is all just pretend!"

My money is on Kris as the killer. She seems the most poised, and I think ABC would tap her to play the killer.

[ddi741]

Did you hear that when the first episodes aired, people were freaking out because they thought ABC was actually killing off the contestants. People are dumb.

[Dumbledork]

The girls that cry and blubber on about how scared they are and how they don't want to die are awful. I just laugh and roll my eyes at them the whole time. So much cheese.

I wondered about viewers taking it too serious after they started showing the "victim" at the end of the episode, alive with murder make up on. Idiots.

[mrsnole]

Dh and I are watching and love it.  We love murder mystery though.  Yes, it's cheesy but it's not supposed to be a drama you know!?
Our pick for the killer is Cam (I think that's his name).

[sparksfly]

Watching it. I am enjoying how they are killing off the contestants!

My guess is that the killer is Lindsey or Melina. Just because in general nobody thinks it is them and I don't think the killer will be an obvious choice.

[ddi741]

I thought maybe the killer is Dana. But also maybe Cam or Lindsey. I honestly have no idea.

Spoiler........










Poor Ulysses, I'm pretty sure he was dead before the horse fell.

[picksthemusic]

I'm putting my money on Melina or Sasha. Sasha is very actressy, and Melina cries too much to be real.

[steph196]

DH was so excited for this show, but couldn't watch past the 2nd episode. I am still watching, but it is indeed very cheese ball. I think that the killer is either Cam or Melina.

[picksthemusic]

I'm now more convinced than ever that Melina is the killer. She acted way too relieved when she got her Spared card, and is still more weepy than ever.

Can't wait for next week's episode! The death this week was super creepy!!

[ddi741]

I still have no idea who the killer was. I had a really hard time figuring out how Ulysses died. Looking forward to the double murder next week.

[picksthemusic]

Bumping this because I want to know what others are thinking about this week's episode! I thought the double murder was a little weird, but whatever. I'm still betting on Melina - but I'm thinking Cris might be it, too, not sure.

Kinda glad the person who got killed is gone.

[Dumbledork]

I'm still betting on Melina, if only because I picked her as the killer in episode 1 and I would love to have picked right from the very beginning. I do agree that a lot of what Cris does makes me suspect her. From finding the board in the house of snakes last week to knowing to bring the scalpel this week to someone how having trusted friends on both sides, she seems to always know exactly what to do next. I think she's too obvious to be the killer though, kinda like Lindsey was a couple weeks ago.

I think Melina is the killer and either Cris or Ronnie will win. Actually, I really want Ronnie to win, but I don't think he will. He seems to be cracking under the pressure a bit. I'd really love Kam to be killed off next so that all the big "leader" people are all gone. He hasn't solved a damn thing on his own to begin with, he's just really good at manipulating people to give him information.

[ddi741]

I really liked the person who got killed at the end of this week. I wanted that person to win. I really dislike Cam and would like to see him gone.

I am still in the 'no idea who the killer is' camp. I'm not sure I even care, I'm just enjoying the show.

[konapoppy]

The Soup's commentary on this show is hysterical.

[Dumbledork]

Yes, I am dragging this back up.

The finale is next week. I'm so pumped my original pick for the murderer, Melina, is still in it. I will be so, so bummed if her disappearance at the end of this week means that she's dead instead of that she's the killer.

On the other hand, I have no idea how Lindsey is even still in it or how she's won multiple rounds. I'm hoping she's only winning so often because of all the information Cris and Kam have given her. But Kam is always so damn confident and Cris has never been scared.

Still, I'm banking on Melina as killer and... Cris as winner. What are your final guesses?

[konapoppy]

I still think Cris is the killer. I initially thought it was Lindsey, but then she seemed too dumb. Melina seems too obvious.

[sparksfly]

I am still torn between Lindsey or Melina being the killer.

[ddi741]

I am still in the 'I don't know / Don't care" camp. I am just really enjoying the show. I was pretty dam proud that I was able to solve Ronnie's murder before they got the clues or anything.
I knew Nitrogen right off the bat and when I saw the 'powdered creamer" I knew it was poison. I apparently watch way too many crime shows.

[mmmomof2]

Worst finale ever! He didn't even know she was the killer!

Did the ever say why Lindsay was acting drunk before they got in the limo?

[Dumbledork]

I'm bummed my guess was wrong, but I'm even more bummed for Lindsey. Girl knew it was Cris from day one and still lost out on all that money. Kam never even had an inkling it was Cris! Terrible ending, so disappointed.