What would be the worst Halloween treat?

[hisno1girl]

Any candy that's not chocolate
Fruit in any form 
Non-candy snacks (chips, popcorn)
Non-food items (crayons, puzzles, toys)
A toothbrush

[luckyval]

Def a tooth brush, unless you go with floss

[wambam]

Toothbrush

[pantsparty]

Pennies.

[agnes]

Oct 28, 2013 9:34:39 GMT -5 pantsparty said:

Pennies.

There was this one house that always gave out pennies AND a full size Hershey bar.  LOVED that house.

[jerseygrl]

one year (I think DD was 4?) my wacky neighbor gave her a can of sprite.  Not the worst but kind of weird.

My other neighbor gave her a pencil. 

[BaliHai]

Yep, toothbrush.

[MixedBerryJam]

Pretty much any toy-type thing is going to be crap (offbrand crayons, one of those puzzles where you have to land little balls in little holes in a cardboard picture, gimp, all of which would just sit it the back of the junk drawer for the next 5 years. And the toothbrush would be an off-brand, no-name toothbrush that is probably $.99 for a three-pack, which I'd also be disinclined to use for anything except grout cleaning.

The worst edible Halloween treat is sour gummies of any kind. They get put directly back into circulation. I don't know who decided sour gummies were a good idea; they were clearly high.

[meggers5]

I would rather have a toothbrush than a box of stale raisins.

[ElizabethBennet]

Bible tracts

[wambam]

Oct 28, 2013 9:42:16 GMT -5 ElizabethBennet said:

Bible tracts

Oh god, I spent like 6 hours on Friday reading through all of the Chick tracts  online. Then I found the no longer printed/out of date ones and they were so much worse. It was hypnotizing.

[CrazyLucky]

What's really the worst is when you get the Reese's PB cup. And you're like, "mmmm, I love Reese's PB cup. I can't wait to eat it." And then you open it up and the PB is all chalky and stale. That's even worse than a toothbrush!