You don't think it's super douchey and suspect to be all "hey, pass the salt. Btw, totes had sex with someone else in 2002."
I don't think that's what happened. Sloan said the wife brought it up and asked him about it.
I guess I see it more like when they started dating, he WAS DATING OTHER WOMEN AT THE TIME and she knew about it but turned a blind eye (exactly how Sloan stated in another reply). 10 years later, it's still bothering her, so she asks about Jane that really friendly bartender she used to see him around town with and he's all, well yeah, I dated her for a while.
this exactly. I mean she says that she thought they were exclusive on a certain date.. he said he didn't feel they were exclusive until much later.she did ask him.
I think it would depend on what exactly she asked him....
"Did you really never sleep with Jane back in '03?" "Well.....I did actually."
Different than:
"How many people were you dating when we started dating?" "Four, and I kept dating 2 until December when we became exclusive." "December?! WE were exclusive in October!" "No we weren't!"