Even though you've already decided I'll jump in and say that I am a 30 year old weirdo who really enjoys More.
I totally flipped through a More at the grocery store today, to see if I would like it. I'm a 26 year old weirdo who reads my mom's Redbook when I'm at her house.
I enjoy More as well. My dentist's office has it and I always find myself wishing they kept me waiting longer so I could finish an article.
But BHG was a good choice. I didn't know anything about it until Readymade went out of business and the publisher substituted it for my last 3 or 4 issues. At first I was like "wtf?" but I really liked it, enough to consider subscribing when I happen upon a good (preferably free) deal.
I just started getting BHG and I like it so far. It's a good mix of things and I like it better than Real Simple, which I tried for a year and decided not to renew. I think that's a good choice.