Do I need Chocolate Bar?

[sporky]

I know, of course, that the correct answer is always YES, but I am actually looking for some objectivity people! 

Also I know this has been asked many times over, but I don't remember the answers, so apologies. 

Here are the palettes I currently own:
Naked 1 and 3
UD Smoked
TF Boudoir Eyes
Lorac Mega Pro
Julep Sweep

I'm a pale-skinned red head so browns are my go-to. I love the swatches for CB but I just don't know how different it may be from what I already have? So, yay or nay?

[secretlyevil]

Eh, I would say no with what you listed.

[Vespasia]

I know I am in the minority here but it is the least used of all my palettes.

[zoomzoom]

I'm no help b/c it's still to new to say. I will say that the more I read on here, the fuller my Sephora basket is getting. Lol.

[mdgirl]

I tried to talk myself into it but it was just too warm for me.

[heyjude]

Probably not, but it's my favorite palette.

[ChillyMcFreeze]

For your coloring, you might want to try Semisweet. It's a lot warmer. But it looks like you have a good collection of neutrals, so you probably don't *need* it. They're both so pretty, though.

[IIOY]

I honestly don't think so, if the colors are the issue.

The one pitch I will make is that I will go ages without using CB and begin to think "meh, whatever." Then I will use it and be amazed all over again by how good the quality of the shadows is. They blend like a dream, possibly the best out of any shadows I own.

Can you live without it though? Yes.

[sporky]

Well, I must say I am pleasantly surprised to see so many no votes, LOL. I can definitely spend that money on something else. Thanks, ladies!

[nursewife]

Apr 10, 2015 16:41:29 GMT -5 @destinationunknown said:

I say no. I actually returned mine- it was really muddy looking on my skin

I'm tempted to return mine as well. I like so many other neutral palettes better.

[hamster]

I planned on getting this during the sale. Now you are making me second guess!

[bonquiqui]

No. I love it, but i love The Semi Sweet WAY more