Which eyeliner do you prefer

[peach]

Nars larger than life eyeliner or urban decay 24/7?

[nursewife]

I hate UD liners. They always seem to end up running down my face. I really want to try the Marc jacobs liners.

[anonymous]

I'm really liking my Bobbi brown gel pot liner

[nursewife]

Also, for liquid liner, I'm currently loving the KVD tattoo liner. Marc Jacobs also has a great liquid.

[ESF]

Jul 20, 2015 20:44:15 GMT -5 nursewife said:

I hate UD liners. They always seem to end up running down my face. I really want to try the Marc jacobs liners.

The Marc Jacobs are fantastic, but they are twist up pencils and I don't love that they aren't easy to sharpen.

I think the UD ones are fine. The NYX slide ons are a third of the price and just as good. I wouldn't bother with UD unless it has a unique color.

The best black pencil I have is from Bobbi Brown.

[nursewife]

Jul 21, 2015 0:21:11 GMT -5 ESF said:

Jul 20, 2015 20:44:15 GMT -5 nursewife said:

I hate UD liners. They always seem to end up running down my face. I really want to try the Marc jacobs liners.

The Marc Jacobs are fantastic, but they are twist up pencils and I don't love that they aren't easy to sharpen.

I think the UD ones are fine. The NYX slide ons are a third of the price and just as good. I wouldn't bother with UD unless it has a unique color.

The best black pencil I have is from Bobbi Brown.

I'd love to try the pink Marc liner. I've seen a few IG posts with it lined rather thick on the lid, and then black liner along the lash line.

[ESF]

Jul 21, 2015 0:23:57 GMT -5 nursewife said:

Jul 21, 2015 0:21:11 GMT -5 ESF said:

The Marc Jacobs are fantastic, but they are twist up pencils and I don't love that they aren't easy to sharpen.

I think the UD ones are fine. The NYX slide ons are a third of the price and just as good. I wouldn't bother with UD unless it has a unique color.

The best black pencil I have is from Bobbi Brown.

I'd love to try the pink Marc liner. I've seen a few IG posts with it lined rather thick on the lid, and then black liner along the lash line.

I have the pink UD, and it's too close of a dupe for me to justify the MJ one. Unfortunately, the UD one is too slide-y, and I've got to load up with primer and go easy on the smudging or it sheers out.

It's hard to use but when I get it right, it's a fun color.

I have the Orange MJ one and it is amazing. I've been wearing it at least twice a week this summer.

[nursewife]

Jul 21, 2015 0:36:05 GMT -5 ESF said:

Jul 21, 2015 0:23:57 GMT -5 nursewife said:

I'd love to try the pink Marc liner. I've seen a few IG posts with it lined rather thick on the lid, and then black liner along the lash line.

I have the pink UD, and it's too close of a dupe for me to justify the MJ one. Unfortunately, the UD one is too slide-y, and I've got to load up with primer and go easy on the smudging or it sheers out.

It's hard to use but when I get it right, it's a fun color.

I have the Orange MJ one and it is amazing. I've been wearing it at least twice a week this summer.

I've really hated the UD liners. Hence why I would like the MJ liner. It kind of drives me insane that UD liners seem like the holy grail since they wear so, so awful on me.

[mrsukyankee]

I tried the UD liner and it went all over. I LOVE the KVD tattoo liner. It's the first that actually has stayed put on me and is easy to use too.

[MarmeeNoir]

Jul 21, 2015 0:39:40 GMT -5 nursewife said:

Jul 21, 2015 0:36:05 GMT -5 ESF said:

I have the pink UD, and it's too close of a dupe for me to justify the MJ one. Unfortunately, the UD one is too slide-y, and I've got to load up with primer and go easy on the smudging or it sheers out.

It's hard to use but when I get it right, it's a fun color.

I have the Orange MJ one and it is amazing. I've been wearing it at least twice a week this summer.

I've really hated the UD liners. Hence why I would like the MJ liner. It kind of drives me insane that UD liners seem like the holy grail since they wear so, so awful on me.

MJ slides on me just as bad if not worse than UD 24/7. On me and I think the 24/7 suck.

[nursewife]

Jul 21, 2015 3:37:52 GMT -5 MarmeeNoir said:

Jul 21, 2015 0:39:40 GMT -5 nursewife said:

I've really hated the UD liners. Hence why I would like the MJ liner. It kind of drives me insane that UD liners seem like the holy grail since they wear so, so awful on me.

MJ slides on me just as bad if not worse than UD 24/7. On me and I think the 24/7 suck.

 Have you found any brands that have staying power?

[MarmeeNoir]

Jul 21, 2015 11:02:06 GMT -5 nursewife said:

Jul 21, 2015 3:37:52 GMT -5 MarmeeNoir said:

MJ slides on me just as bad if not worse than UD 24/7. On me and I think the 24/7 suck.

 Have you found any brands that have staying power?

Not in pencil form. MAC gel eyeliner does, but it's not black enough for me

[nursewife]

Jul 21, 2015 11:08:33 GMT -5 MarmeeNoir said:

Jul 21, 2015 11:02:06 GMT -5 nursewife said:

 Have you found any brands that have staying power?

Not in pencil form. MAC gel eyeliner does, but it's not black enough for me

I'm just looking for something with fun colours as I use liquid instead of pencil for my every day makeup.

[SallyJ]

I hate the UD 24/7 liners. They run everywhere, especially the black, brown and navy. I have a turquoise and purple one that aren't too bad. I prefer Mally eyeliner for staying power for basic colors.

[secretlyevil]

Mally
NYX WP


I have a couple UDs that work great but theirs are mostly fails for me, specifically the "basic" colors.

I have yet to find a HG black. My mally black velvet isn't a jet black.