Which neutral heel?

[spedrunner]

Girls, Please help me out. I can not decide between these two :

1 - www.ninewest.com/Caress/9708137,default,pd.html?variantSizeClass=&variantColor=JJ7WMA8&cgid=8346252&prefn1=catalog-id&prefv1=ninewest-catalog
IN LIGHT BROWN PATENT LEATER
OR

2- www.ninewest.com/Martina/8103637,default,pd.html?variantSizeClass=&variantColor=TORTAPA&cgid=8346252&prefn1=catalog-id&prefv1=ninewest-catalog\

NUDE

I worry the martina nude heel will be too pointy and make me feet look like long boats

Ive tried #1 on and liked, i didnt realize they werent truly a "nude" color though until i compare the two

[lostarz]

I almost bought the Caress the other day, but it the light natural leather (it wasn't patent).

I also considered the Martina pair. I bought neither because I really didn't need them lol.

FWIW, here's a pic of Veronika in the Martina...I like them.

veronabrit.blogspot.com/2012/07/sweaters-for-summer.html

[spedrunner]

yeah i LOVE them on veronika Not sure how they will look on my foot tho.....

Yes, i tried on the natural leather and HATED It in caress, it looks like part of my foot (same color LOL)

[crispnclean]

I like the first pair best. Both the color and the shape.

If you like the style of the Caress but your hangup is on the color, did you see they have the Caress in a light leather?
www.ninewest.com/Caress/6279317,default,pd.html?omn=cross-sell&omnsource=9708137

The Caress also comes in a taupe:
www.ninewest.com/Caress/6279317,default,pd.html?omn=cross-sell&omnsource=9708137

[crispnclean]

Aug 31, 2012 13:21:09 GMT -5 spedrunner said:

yeah i LOVE them on veronika Not sure how they will look on my foot tho.....

Yes, i tried on the natural leather and HATED It in caress, it looks like part of my foot (same color LOL)

Oops, didn't see this response before I posted.

[karebear304]

I like the Martina, but I like pointy toe in general.

[wawa]

I like the martina, but I think they look very similar to the old ninewests that I'm wearing in OOTD. They're the only pointy shoes I've ever worn that didn't feel like witch shoes. I think ninewest does pointy toes well.

[fashionx]

I like the first one, Caress.