Winter

[noodleskooze]

Nov 28, 2016 17:39:11 GMT -5 momof2 said:

I have only watched this one, and I am now questioning why I ever liked this show. There was nothing likable about any character except Emily. Even Luke acted like an overgrown teenager. I think I'm too old for this, but will likely watch the rest of the episodes just to have closure.

If you didn't like Winter, I doubt the rest are worth your time...it was the best of the four, IMO.

[vanlatte]

Nov 28, 2016 17:39:11 GMT -5 momof2 said:

I have only watched this one, and I am now questioning why I ever liked this show. There was nothing likable about any character except Emily. Even Luke acted like an overgrown teenager. I think I'm too old for this, but will likely watch the rest of the episodes just to have closure.

Either way, don't expect closure.

[egeiger]

I am late to the party, obviously, and don't expect a reply. But I had to post my gripes somewhere. I am not thrilled but I didn't have super high expectations either. I just do not find the casual sleeping with Logan thing believable at all. You dated for three years, he proposed, and you said no. Who on earth casually goes back to that ? Not with Logan's ego, and not the girl who lost her mind and thought things were over because she lost Dean's bracelet. I don't care so much about the Paul scenario being unbelievable because he is in a base character. But the Logan thing… Makes it hard for me to want to watch anymore

[dana2006]

Finished it yesterday. The biggest thing that stood out to me was Lorelai's performance at her father's funeral. It was painful to watch. I kept thinking why can't the producers give her a little more dignity? she's almost 50, for crying out loud, far beyond the age of drunken teenager level rambling.

[ciescalove]

Watching it now. Someone on the radio spoiled the end for me, which pissed me off, but oh well. I don't feel about this like I thought I would. I don't hate it, but I'm an hour in and I'm not sure if I love it either.

Paris running a surrogacy agency is... unexpected.

[wambam]

Dec 2, 2016 7:41:38 GMT -5 egeiger said:

I am late to the party, obviously, and don't expect a reply. But I had to post my gripes somewhere. I am not thrilled but I didn't have super high expectations either. I just do not find the casual sleeping with Logan thing believable at all. You dated for three years, he proposed, and you said no. Who on earth casually goes back to that ? Not with Logan's ego, and not the girl who lost her mind and thought things were over because she lost Dean's bracelet. I don't care so much about the Paul scenario being unbelievable because he is in a base character. But the Logan thing… Makes it hard for me to want to watch anymore

I think the fact that Logan is in London (and that it was never brought up) means that ASP is just ignoring the proposal.

[kittycatlove]

Dec 6, 2016 12:00:59 GMT -5 wambam said:

Dec 2, 2016 7:41:38 GMT -5 egeiger said:

I am late to the party, obviously, and don't expect a reply. But I had to post my gripes somewhere. I am not thrilled but I didn't have super high expectations either. I just do not find the casual sleeping with Logan thing believable at all. You dated for three years, he proposed, and you said no. Who on earth casually goes back to that ? Not with Logan's ego, and not the girl who lost her mind and thought things were over because she lost Dean's bracelet. I don't care so much about the Paul scenario being unbelievable because he is in a base character. But the Logan thing… Makes it hard for me to want to watch anymore

I think the fact that Logan is in London (and that it was never brought up) means that ASP is just ignoring the proposal.

I agree. I think ASP just wrote this whole revival how she always envisioned the show so essentially season 7 never happened.

[mysticmuffin]

Dec 6, 2016 12:00:59 GMT -5 wambam said:

Dec 2, 2016 7:41:38 GMT -5 egeiger said:

I am late to the party, obviously, and don't expect a reply. But I had to post my gripes somewhere. I am not thrilled but I didn't have super high expectations either. I just do not find the casual sleeping with Logan thing believable at all. You dated for three years, he proposed, and you said no. Who on earth casually goes back to that ? Not with Logan's ego, and not the girl who lost her mind and thought things were over because she lost Dean's bracelet. I don't care so much about the Paul scenario being unbelievable because he is in a base character. But the Logan thing… Makes it hard for me to want to watch anymore

I think the fact that Logan is in London (and that it was never brought up) means that ASP is just ignoring the proposal.

This wouldn't surprise me from ASP. It did make me ponder what would have happened in those years to get him from San Fran back to London.