I personally prefer the first picture, it looks more intentional. The only reason I might consider the second one is if your natural lighting isn't that great.
I think doing something like this will look very out of proportion unless you replace all the baseboard molding (and probably also molding throughout) with something more substantial than what I see in your 3rd pic above.
Honestly I don't think you're opening is big enough to add more flow impediment with pony walls. You would be going from 11' to probably 8' before trim. I would tape it out and see if you can really live with it.
I think defining the spaces with built-ins around your fireplace would be a much better use of time and money.
If you do this, the first option looks better. However, I do agree with the others that the space will be tight if you do this; plus, IMO the space between the pony wall and the fireplace will be awkward.
Post by thatgirl2478 on Dec 30, 2016 22:30:45 GMT -5
So, I like option 1 better. However, I agree that the space between the fireplace and pony wall would be awkward. How much space would be in that area if you went with the pony wall?
I don't think the 8' opening would be a problem - our door between the living room & dining room is only 6' and it's fine.