Need a new mascara - what is your fave?

[gennyu]

I love BareMinerals products but not the Lash Domination mascara.  I find it flakes under my eyes.  I have some Ulta rewards to cash in and want to try something new.  What is your favorite mascara?

[sporky]

My favorites are all Lancome. I haven't had a bad one from them yet.

[stephm0188]

It Cosmetics Supehero.

[wawa]

I always go back to benefit roller lash for daytime.

Ulta brand assorted types as pretty good too.

[wineandcheese]

Benefit roller lash or too faced better then sex are my go tos.

I like wet n wild waterproof mascara for my lower lashes. I'm not sure of the name but it's in the purple tube.

[Pippin]

I'm really liking UD Perversion right now. Otherwise TF Better Than Sex is another favorite.

[racegrrl714]

benefit roller lash or it superhero

[bunnies]

I go cheap on mascara since it's a frequently replaced product. L'oreal Voluminous is my fave.

[rondonalddo]

I love Stila Huge , but I just went back to Rimmel Scandaleyes Retro Glam, which has a similar brush, and I love it too, just a little less than the Stila. Similar brush shape.

[pooh8402]

Too Faced Better Than Sex, or Cover Girl Volume (the orange tube) for a cheap option.

[Miss Phryne Fisher]

I am currently liking Lash Paradise

[racegrrl714]

I also love Too Faced BTS, but it does give me raccoon eyes after a long day.

[pizzanight]

Benefit roller lash for the top and Revlon mega multiplier on the bottom - the Revlon is a tube mascara so it doesn't flake.

[gennyu]

Loving all these recommendations! I went ahead and bought the Benefit Roller Lash w my 20% off no exclusions coupon at ultra. But I'm really intrigued by tube mascara - I had never heard of this before. Does anyone use the Clinique Lash Power? Clinique is another Dave brand of mine.

[mrsukyankee]

Aug 12, 2017 17:45:08 GMT -5 gennyu said:

Loving all these recommendations! I went ahead and bought the Benefit Roller Lash w my 20% off no exclusions coupon at ultra. But I'm really intrigued by tube mascara - I had never heard of this before. Does anyone use the Clinique Lash Power? Clinique is another Dave brand of mine.

Yup - have used it for years.  It's awesome for those of us with oily lids.

[calico]

I didn't know Revlon had a tubing mascara! I'll have to check that out. I just bought the No 7 tubing mascara to try. I love having more affordable options for this, so I hope they work out as well as my favorite Blinc mascara.

[beetea]

I have super oily lids and love the Clinique Lash Power, Benefit Roller Girl, and the new L'Oreal Lash Paradise. I have to make sure I use an eye primer and really set it to avoid smudges with the Roller Girl and Lash Paradise.

[cottoncandy]

Aug 12, 2017 17:45:08 GMT -5 gennyu said:

Loving all these recommendations! I went ahead and bought the Benefit Roller Lash w my 20% off no exclusions coupon at ultra. But I'm really intrigued by tube mascara - I had never heard of this before. Does anyone use the Clinique Lash Power? Clinique is another Dave brand of mine.

I have been using lash power for years on my bottom lashes. As long as I have a tube mascara on the bottom, i don't get raccoon eyes. (Except TF better than sex. Love the look, but it always end up under my eyes.) I just got the new revlon tube mascara, and it works just as well as the lash power. It will be my new go too for as long as they make it:-)

[larzhope]

Aug 12, 2017 17:45:08 GMT -5 gennyu said:

Loving all these recommendations! I went ahead and bought the Benefit Roller Lash w my 20% off no exclusions coupon at ultra. But I'm really intrigued by tube mascara - I had never heard of this before. Does anyone use the Clinique Lash Power? Clinique is another Dave brand of mine.

i use Trish McEvoy tube mascara and it is incredible.  it is literally the only mascara that doesn't smudge under my eyes by end of day.

[calico]

I like UD Perversion and TF BTS, but they smudge like a mother on me. Lash Paradise is amazing and hedging out Tarte LCL as my favorite regular mascara.

[Champagne Supernova]

Another vote for UD Perversion and Too Faced Better Than Sex. I have thin and shirt lashes but both give me volume like whoa.

I recommend using a lash primer when using them though. They give me raccoon eyes whenever I skip the lash primer.

[Crystal]

Aug 12, 2017 11:35:28 GMT -5 Pippin said:

I'm really liking UD Perversion right now. Otherwise TF Better Than Sex is another favorite.

These are the two I use most.

I got a sampler set from Sephora during the holidays. It had 10 smaller tubes in it, plus two full size. I haven't really found one I don't like in there, although some of the applicators were a little rougher than I like, so I gave them to my daughter.

[mrssandro]

I have tried so many but I find this drugstore brand is the best. I do have to replace it more than I like but that is fine. 

[niki]

Urban Decay Perversion here too!

[Pippin]

Aug 14, 2017 13:37:52 GMT -5 mrssandro said:

I have tried so many but I fine this drugstore brand is the best. I do have to replace it more than I like but that is fine. 

I need to try this one. I have yet to find a drugstore mascara that works for me. Lash Paradise was a total fail which sucks because I loved the wand.

[kategm]

Lash Sensational user here too. I also really like Maybelline The Rocket, but Lash Sensational is a bit blacker so it edges out.

I bought the Lash Paradise and it's ok. I don't love the brush, and I feel like it can clump if you're not careful. I see more volume difference rather than length. ETA: also, its a bit smudgier than the Maybelline ones.

[veruca5839]

Tarte Maneater is my favorite. L'Oreal Lash Paradise is another favorite.

[blondemoment123]

My holy grail is Benefit Yes They're Real.

[secretlyevil]

UD perversion, MUFE's smokey extravaganza and Essence's WP mascara in the blue tube, actual name is completely escaping me.

[NewGirlNic]

I have a few I like, for different occasions.
Tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes is my favorite for dramatic/full lashes
L'Oreal Double Extend is a tube mascara and I like it for hot/humid weather because it doesn't budge or smear
Benefit Roller Lash is my go-to when I travel or am in a hurry since I don't need to use a lash curler with it (my lashes are stick straight and this really does curl them)

I also like the Covergirl in the orange tube and Maybelline Colossal Effect (yellow tube)