Washable mascara recs needed please

[jordancatalano4ever]

I have tried so many mascaras (Nars, smashbox, tarte, urban decay, Stila, Dior, lancome, Estée Lauder, too faced, benefit, cover girl, almay) but of everything I’ve tried my favorite has been Clinique high impact because it washes off so easily. But it’s not very volumizing. Anyone have a favorite that washes easily and has good volume/lift? TIA

[calico]

I like the Blinc amplify tubing mascara.

[cosmowife]

I’ve only ever had luck with cover girl mascaras (and I’ve tried a bunch too)

[pooh8402]

Odd, the Clinique High Impact that I've been using is SO HARD to wash off. I like the volume (not as big as TF BTS or CG orange tube but okay) but it stays put. I use makeup remover for waterproof makeup AND my face wash, and I still have black smudges under my eyes in the morning.

So if you want big lashes and the mascara washes off easily, my rec is Too Faced Better Than Sex or Cover Girl Lash Blast in the orange tube. You said you'd already tried these brands, but did not mention which actual mascaras. These give me my favorite lash looks.

[tiramisu]

Maybelline Full N Soft washes off pretty cleanly on me and I think it gives a nice effect. Not TONS of volume, but it does add some, IMO.

[centralsquare]

I have been wearing this Trish McEvoy for 10+ years. I will never go back to non-tube mascara.

Check out the High Volume Mascara from Nordstrom: shop.nordstrom.com/S/2811716

[jordancatalano4ever]

Aug 29, 2018 6:14:23 GMT -5 pooh8402 said:

Odd, the Clinique High Impact that I've been using is SO HARD to wash off. I like the volume (not as big as TF BTS or CG orange tube but okay) but it stays put. I use makeup remover for waterproof makeup AND my face wash, and I still have black smudges under my eyes in the morning.

So if you want big lashes and the mascara washes off easily, my rec is Too Faced Better Than Sex or Cover Girl Lash Blast in the orange tube. You said you'd already tried these brands, but did not mention which actual mascaras. These give me my favorite lash looks.

I own/owned both respectively. I think mascara is the one item I have tried the most and never found a holy grail for.
Just for clarification my list specifically:
Nars audacious
smashbox full exposure
tarte lights cameras lashes
urban decay perversion
Stila huge extreme lash
Diorshow
lancome hypnose and grandiose
Estée Lauder double wear
too faced better than sex
Buxom lash volumizing
benefit bad girl, they’re real
Bare minerals lash domination
cover girl lash blast
almay thickening

I know I need to be looking for tubing but I can’t find that info on the labels. It’s frustrating

[pooh8402]

I haven't found a good volumizing tubing mascara. I'm looking at that Trish McEvoy linked above and I can already tell I won't like the brush. Not fluffy/big enough.

[kittycatlove]

How about Loreal Voluminous? I haven't used it in a while, but it used to be one of my favorites and I don't think it was too difficult to remove.

[persa]

What are you using to wash? I find oil based (like face shop rice oil) or balms like clean it zero or Clinique take the day off to be the best options

[cosmowife]

Aug 29, 2018 16:46:00 GMT -5 centralsquare said:

I have been wearing this Trish McEvoy for 10+ years. I will never go back to non-tube mascara.

Check out the High Volume Mascara from Nordstrom: shop.nordstrom.com/S/2811716

Do you have to use some sort of special technique to get it to wash off? And does it really not smudge?

[centralsquare]

Aug 30, 2018 16:25:52 GMT -5 cosmowife said:

Aug 29, 2018 16:46:00 GMT -5 centralsquare said:

I have been wearing this Trish McEvoy for 10+ years. I will never go back to non-tube mascara.

Check out the High Volume Mascara from Nordstrom: shop.nordstrom.com/S/2811716

Do you have to use some sort of special technique to get it to wash off? And does it really not smudge?

Not really. Get it wet. Gently pull it off in tubes. No smudging.

[auntie]

Tubing mascara.