What to give away/what to keep?

[minionkevin]

I bought the ABH Sultry palette and UD Naked Cherry during the Sephora sale. They came yesterday and I don’t want to keep both. DH’s cousin is reallllly into makeup, and always looks 100x better than I do (her applications are Instagram pro worthy). I usually get her an Ulta gc and last year (I think?) I bought her a Morphe palette. I am under a time crunch to get her a Christmas present bc we are exchanging with DH’s extended family next Sunday.
I am pale, light ash brown hair, green eyes, very cool/pink undertones.
She is Native American/Guatemalan, black hair, brown eyes, warmer undertones.
Which would you keep vs. give away?

[persa]

Nov 17, 2018 12:40:03 GMT -5 minionkevin said:

I bought the ABH Sultry palette and UD Naked Cherry during the Sephora sale. They came yesterday and I don’t want to keep both. DH’s cousin is reallllly into makeup, and always looks 100x better than I do (her applications are Instagram pro worthy). I usually get her an Ulta gc and last year (I think?) I bought her a Morphe palette. I am under a time crunch to get her a Christmas present bc we are exchanging with DH’s extended family next Sunday.
I am pale, light ash brown hair, green eyes, very cool/pink undertones.
She is Native American/Guatemalan, black hair, brown eyes, warmer undertones.
Which would you keep vs. give away?

She'd probably be better suited to the Naked Cherry I think. Is there any chance she would have bought it for herself though?

[Pippin]

I’d keep Sultry but that’s because I’m loving that palette right now. I’d check and make sure she doesn’t already have one or both of those palettes before gifting though.

[minionkevin]

She typically doesn’t buy anything @ full price. Her hauls are things she finds @ Marshall’s, TJ Maxx, Nordstrom Rack, etc.
I think both are too new for her to have found where she shops and subsequently purchased (she works at one of the stores I listed above so she also gets a discount).