Rose cleansing stick replacement

[centralsquare]

Anyone found anything they like? My Belif stick (also discontinued) is on its last legs... 😭

[wawa]

Nope. Abandon all hope. Stick cleansers were a cruel trick.

[Pippin]

I thought I saw some brand come out with a cleansing stick recently. Maybe the ColourPop skincare line? I’ll look around but I thought that was cool. Maybe they’ll start making a come back.

[ESF]

Nope. There's a few things that are OK and would have been acceptable had I experienced the magic of the cleaning stick.

I use CeraVe for my in the shower face washing.

I keep this DE bar soap on my sink for non-shower face washing. www.sephora.com/product/baby-bar-travel-duo-with-case-P440658

I got this powder cleanser from a subscription box last month, and now that's on my sink too. www.hanaleicompany.com/products/papaya-enyzme-powder-face-cleanser

I really just want a stick. I don't understand why Drunk Elephant or any of these other bar soap makers can't just pour their soap in a giant chapstick tube. This cannot be that hard.

[NewOrleans]

No. And the cleanser (not stick) I wanted to try was also discontinued.

::weep::

[calico]

My stick is almost gone too. I've started using the white DE bar (I can never keep the name straight- is it Juju or peekee?)

[centralsquare]

The stick is damn convenient. But I would buy that rose cleanser in a bar if they made it. And I hate bar soap!!

Le sigh.

[followyourarrow]

Pretty sure amazon is tracking me. They just suggested this. Neogen Real Fresh Cleansing Stick Green Tea 80g www.amazon.com/dp/B01GODUBGE/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_Z89iDbC5F31WA

[gottadobe]

Puremay has a rose cleansing stick.

[bowies]

Acure has a stick, available at Target. It’s good!

[wawa]

Fyi the neogen is on the Reddit ph list at 5.5. The others aren't listed. The puremay one sounds promising though.

Eta: gothamista says the acure is a 6 and likes it

[ESF]

I'm ordering the Neogen green tea one. I'll report back!

[wawa]

Jul 14, 2019 9:58:39 GMT -5 ESF said:

I'm ordering the Neogen green tea one. I'll report back!

Discontinued in 3...2...

[calico]

Jul 14, 2019 9:58:39 GMT -5 ESF said:

I'm ordering the Neogen green tea one. I'll report back!

Thoughts after using it for a while?

[ESF]

Sept 12, 2019 21:39:18 GMT -5 calico said:

Jul 14, 2019 9:58:39 GMT -5 ESF said:

I'm ordering the Neogen green tea one. I'll report back!

Thoughts after using it for a while?

Confession: I've currently got five cleansers - the two DE bars, a powder cleanser I got in a subscription box, the CeraVe, and the Neogen. I'm moving cross country in two weeks so I'm trying to use up the non stick products, so I haven't used the Neogen that many times.

My initial impression is that it's very good and I'd buy it again.  I liked the Belif stick better than the Rose stick, but the Rose stick was still my second favorite and leaps and bounds better than anything else. It's not quite as creamy as the other two, and I loooooved the Belif scent. But I still really like it. It works like a stick and doesn't dry my skin out, and that's all I care about.

I will throw out my other cleansers and the Neogen is the only thing coming with me.

[secretlyevil]

I don’t understand why a stick cleanser is so much better? :: ducks for cover::

[wawa]

Sept 20, 2019 5:38:08 GMT -5 secretlyevil said:

I don’t understand why a stick cleanser is so much better? :: ducks for cover::

For me it's because it goes in my gym bag and anywhere else I travel. I just use a pump liquid at my sink at home, but for travel this format is A++.

[secretlyevil]

Sept 20, 2019 7:50:21 GMT -5 wawa said:

Sept 20, 2019 5:38:08 GMT -5 secretlyevil said:

I don’t understand why a stick cleanser is so much better? :: ducks for cover::

For me it's because it goes in my gym bag and anywhere else I travel. I just use a pump liquid at my sink at home, but for travel this format is A++.

That does make a lot of sense. 

So now I have a Neogen Green Tea Cleansing Stick and a new lip sleeping mask on its way to me. 

[calico]

secretlyevil, there were 2 things about the Sum cleanser that made it my HG: 1) the stick form never got gross and mushy 2) the formula of the cleanser was phenomenal for my skin

So...yea. Bummed AF, over here.