Sail shade color help - Updated with pics

[Pilsy]

Our siding is Boothbay Blue fiber cement (Hardie board), and our trim is white. We have a patio made of gray stone pavers and want to install a sail shade on the side of the house, extended out to a couple poles we'll install in the lawn. 

Which color would you do for the sail? Link here

We think white will show to much grime, so I'm leaning toward gray, and my husband is thinking brown. He thinks brown is a better contrast, whereas I think it means introducing another color unnecessarily.

[Updated with pics below.]

Thanks!

[InBetweenDays]

I'd either do gray, or if you want a pop of color I'd consider red (unless that would clash with patio furniture/cushions).

I definitely wouldn't do white, and wouldn't do brown with the gray patio stones.

[nicolewi]

Out of those choices, with your colors, I would go with gray for sure! I feel like brown would be weird.

FYI Costco often has things like this in spring for a great price, if you do Costco. Not sure what they have this year as I haven't been there for over a month due to Covid.

[Pilsy]

PDQ pics. 

The area at the end, where it's sort of sectioned off, is the area we plan to cover. I'll be back to ask for a patio table rec!

[Pilsy]

InBetweenDays, nicolewi

Thank you both!

I'm going to see if the red is a true red, as we have red doors, and I'd love the pop of color, but not if it's at all orangey. If that's a bust, gray it is.

Thanks again.

[RockNVoll]

I like the red. A pop of color would be great back there and I don't think it needs to match the doors. You can't see much of the door color behind that screen door anyways.

[InBetweenDays]

Hmm, looking at those photos your pavers look more brown than gray to me. But maybe it's the lighting in the photo?

I think red would look great.

[nicolewi]

I like the red idea, too, especially with the red door! The red in the item listing did look orangey, though. I had also thought yellow would be fun and cheery but it wasn't offered.

[Pilsy]

Thanks, all. I agree the pavers don't look as gray in the pics as they do in real life.

We went with the gray, because neither of us really wants orange (less because of the doors and more because we just don't love orange), and my H thinks even a very red one will fade to a color he doesn't like with time.

We do need some color, though, so I'm planning to hang bright plants from the pole we use for the shade. Maybe some pillows on the patio set, too.