Birthday Cake Poll

[lilafowler]

My birthday is next week. I can’t decide on whether I want ice cream or regular cake. I need to order soonish because Christmas and New Years can impact when things are open.

If you’re on app the options are:

Ice Cream cake
Regular cake
SS

[momin2013]

SS: my absolute favourite is from Baskin Robbins and is a layer of chocolate cake and a layer of gold medal ribbon ice cream, with their fudge topping instead of frosting. YWIA

[lilafowler]

By regular cake I mean a cake from a bakery with lots of frosting flowers (I love frosting).

BUT I also love that ridiculous weird ice cream cake frosting.

[pierogigirl]

Regular cake, but I don't like ice cream.

[underwaterrhymes]

Ice cream cake every time

[underwaterrhymes]

And happy birthday!

[devonpow]

Ice cream. JP licks Oreo ice cream cake specifically

[bugandbibs]

You can’t go wrong with either.

[sweetchix]

SS - my favorite is homemade yellow cake with chocolate fudge frosting with LOTS of candy sprinkles 😋

ETA but if I had to choose out of your choice, I’d pick ice cream cake. I love the chocolate layer!

[fryjack2]

Jp licks Oreo cake batter is what we order for every birthday.

I don’t like cake or frosting, though.

[gummybear]

I love ice cream cake but I’ve been so damn cold lately I’d pick the bakery cake. I love frosting and I love a good bakery cake too.

But to scratch the ice cream cake itch I’d prob also get that little baskin robins one from the grocery store (it’s $10) and scrape off all the frosting and eat the crunchies bc it’s my birthday goddammit.

[VillainV]

Ugh, torn. I don’t particularly care for cake, but I’m also lactose intolerant. I’d probably pop a lactaid and go for the ice cream cake.

[icedcoffee]

Get both!! YOLO!

[jinkies]

I am realizing now that everyone is my family has their signature birthday dessert so there is never a decision to make. I get strawberry pie.

I chose the I hate everything option (sorry! I don't really hate you! But I do hate frosting and am lactose intolerant) I think I'd choose the bakery cake though.

Happy birthday!!

[basilosaurus]

Pie

[HRH Queen Dick I]

People, Lila and her family go HAM on cakes. Thuper therious business. Pies or any other desserts are not an option.

[tacokick]

I’d get both and get a smaller regular cake. It’s not like you have to eat the whole ice cream cake in one sitting.

[silvercrayon]

The Cookies & Creamery Cake from Cold Stone!!!

[gummy]

I'm not a fan of ice cream cake, though I love ice cream. I'm team bakery cake with too much questionable food dye frosting.

[cville]

Ice cream: yes!
Cake: yes!
Ice cream cake: why, God, why?!?!

Anyway, bakery cake all the damn way.

[mcmel]

Cookie cake or bakery classic cake with a ton of icing

[livinitup]

I can’t decide either !

[jackie011]

I just had a DQ cake last month for my birthday and it was so disappointing.

[mcppalmbeach]

Oh that’s hard! I usually alternate between ice cream cake and a specialty cake from a local restaurant (it’s called a banana dream cake and it’s freaking amazing). And for my kids I alternate between a bakery cake or a cookie cake. So I cover my bases throughout the year lol. I vote whichever you’re less likely to have soon!

[UMaineTeach]

I was already going to pick ice cream cake, but your favorite cake is not mine. It’s good, but I’m not going out of my way to order white or marble cake.

[Susie]

I bake scratch cakes for everybody's birthdays but mine.

For mine, I have H get me a really good cheesecake.

[chickadee77]

Dairy doesn't like me anymore, so regular cake.

Womp womp.

[sofamonkey]

If they did a peanut buster parfait ice cream cake, I’d fuck that up.

I don’t see how you can make a wrong choice here. I’d only slightly lean more towards regular cake due to the temps, but it’s such a minute amount. Lol. I agree with whoever said both.

[basilosaurus]

Dec 20, 2023 21:14:20 GMT -5 HRH Queen Dick I said:

People, Lila and her family go HAM on cakes. Thuper therious business. Pies or any other desserts are not an option.

ok, fine, dick, tiramisu ice cream cake. Boozy ice creams layered with lady fingers. Cake AND ice cream. I made this once and it was a huge hit

[jlt19]

Growing up, the DQ by us sold “cupcakes” and they were amazing. The crunchy chewy fudge center was a bigger ratio too, so it made it even better. Maybe try that when you’re out and about on your own?

I love bakery cake and a glass of cold milk. And I’m a corner with a flower piece girl myself. Give me all the sugar!