Come in if you tightline

[electricmayhem]

I just learned about this and need some recommendations for product.

Right now I am using a Rimmel liquid liner (b/c that's what I had on hand). It works, and I like the way it looks, but the liner gets on my lower lash line pretty often.

I read a ton of reviews on MUA for Mac's Blacktrack vs the UD 24/7 pencil. Any pros or cons for these (or another product I should consider). If it matters, I wear contacts.

[ijack]

I had it done at the LM counter the other day and it stayed really well - but it may be a little harder than using a pencil.

[persa]

I use stila waterproof liquid eyeliner and I really like it.

[kittycatlove]

I've never tried tightlining with anything but a pencil, I can't imagine how I wouldn't poke my eye out with a brush but I might have to try it. I use both UD 24/7 in Zero and MAC Smolder.

[electricmayhem]

The Rimmel brush actually makes it really easy to tightline, but the liquid is pretty thin, so if I don't get it right on the first swipe, I'm usually SOL b/c adding more makes it bleed into my eyes. I was thinking maybe a pencil would be easier too, but then saw a few videos on YouTube using Blacktrack with a liner brush.

[ijack]

at LM they did it with their flat eyeliner brush and said to get the liner to the consistency of "shoe polish." It didn't seem to be messy at all - she said she looks down into a mirror and then kind of pushes her lid down with her finger to make the eyelash line pop out a little and make it easier to reach.

[persa]

I tight line from underneath with my stila eyeliner pen

[StJess80]

www.sephora.com/emphaseyes-high-definition-eye-pencil-P190037?om_mmc=Googlepla&_requestid=42976&cm_mmc=us_search-_-GG-_-pla-_-{keyword}&ci_src=17588969&ci_sku=1087022

This is one of the best, I think. Although, BM has a pencil that works really well, IMO. I've done it w/ liquid, but it's harder. I prefer pencil (esp for the top) but gel/pots work good too.