WDYT of these curtains?

[Deleted]

www1.macys.com/shop/product/softline-window-treatments-element-tree-collection?ID=642476&PseudoCat=se-xx-xx-xx.esn_results

One minute I love them (they're quirky weird like me). The next I'm kind of meh.

In the black and silver.

I have coupons so they're a fairly decent deal (I need 8 and in longer lengths!). My house is pretty plain right now. Black/white accented with red and lime. I'm a bit modern country, a bit quirky antiquey and a bit traditional.

Any other suggestions? I need less than $35.00 a panel and longer lengths (96 and 108). I don't have time or ambish to deal with sewing extra on the bottom right now either.

[thewop]

Me likey.

[sierramist03]

I like but I'm not sure I love them. Just something is off. I'm not sure what. I bet they could look really nice in a room though.

[auntie]

They lost me with grommets. I think the silver would bother me over time, I'd have to see them IRL.

How about these? They're sort of quirky-
www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/40210925/

[Deleted]

Nov 29, 2012 10:55:02 GMT -5 auntie said:

They lost me with grommets. I think the silver would bother me over time, I'd have to see them IRL.

How about these? They're sort of quirky-
www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/40210925/

I saw those at IKEA when I was there yesterday actually. I didn't love the quality and they're waaayy to white for my house. I like the concept though.

[munkii]

They're ok but would be a million times better if they had fewer, more substantial trees and fewer branches. The amount of branches makes it kind of halloween-like to me.

[pitterwoo]

I like them in theory, but I wish that the pattern was a little bigger and spaced out because at first glance it doesn't look like trees and branches to me. For some reason I just feel like these would be something I'd tire of quicker than I'd want to be replacing curtains.

[peach]

me no likey

[Deleted]

Nov 29, 2012 11:07:44 GMT -5 munkii said:

They're ok but would be a million times better if they had fewer, more substantial trees and fewer branches. The amount of branches makes it kind of halloween-like to me.

I think this is my issue with them as well! I love them but maybe only because it's still fallish/warm/cozy. During Christmas and the dead of summer I might find them creepy.

I'll keep looking I think.