Rank the following Halloween candies.

[TrickyBob]

Swedish fish
Skittles
M&M's

[textbookcase]

Top 3 faves:
PB cups
Skittles
Snickers

Least:
Smarties
Necco wafers
Mary Janes

[polka]

Out of that list, my 3 favorite would be snickers, m & m's original and peanut.

My least favorite from that list would be good n plenty, candy corn and dots.

[bananapancakes]

Top 3- Reese PB cups, M&M peanut, M&M plain

Bottom 3- Necco wafers, Good n Plenty, Smarties ( I assume you mean the American ones and not the delicious Canadian Smarties which would be in my top 3.)

[polka]

Oct 31, 2012 18:09:32 GMT -5 kevin arnold said:

My top 3 are Kit Kat, Snickers, and Butterfinger.

Bottom 3 are Necco Wafers, Twizzlers and Good & Plenty.

I didn't see kit kats in that list, missy! Or I would have put those in my top 3! Lol

[underwaterrhymes]

Top 3
Butterfingers and Snickers tied
Sour Patch Kids and Twizzlers tied
Mary Janes

Bottom 3
Candy Corn
Necco Wafers
Smarties

[melindafelinda]

From this list. Top three: snickers, starburst, candy corn

Bottom 3: necco wafers, good and plenty, smarties (both chalk and chocolate varieties)

[fuckstick]

Oct 31, 2012 18:07:34 GMT -5 kevin arnold said:

Or pick your top 3 favorites, and 3 least favorites from the list.

Butterfingers- 1
Candy Corn - satan's asshole
Dots- no
Dum Dums (your fav flavor)- orange
Good n Plenty-fuck naw
Laffy Taffy- 4
Mary Janes - what is this shit?
M&Ms, original- if nothing else better is left
Necco Wafers - give to dad
Peanut M&Ms- 3
Reese's PB cups- 2
Skittles- 4
Smarties- 7
Snickers- 5
Sour Patch Kids- yes
Starburst- 4.5
Swedish Fish- gross
Tootsie Rolls- give to mom
Twizzlers - give to mom
Whoppers - turd balls

My rating system may seem arbitrary but it is highly scientific and accurate.

[annyong]

Top three: snickers, butterfingers, and Reese's pb cups.

Bottom three: candy corn, good n plenty, necco wafers.

[annyong]

Oct 31, 2012 18:09:32 GMT -5 kevin arnold said:

My top 3 are Kit Kat, Snickers, and Butterfinger.

Bottom 3 are Necco Wafers, Twizzlers and Good & Plenty.

Kit Kats are not on the list! Cheater!

[kellykapowski]

Top three: Candy corn, Dots and Necco Wafers

Bottom three: M&Ms (I had a fight with them in 1984 and I've hated them since. I fought with hot dogs too in case you care), Tootsie Rolls and Whoppers. YUCK!

[bananapancakes]

Oct 31, 2012 18:13:48 GMT -5 kevin arnold said:

Oct 31, 2012 18:10:36 GMT -5 bananapancakes said:

Top 3- Reese PB cups, M&M peanut, M&M plain

Bottom 3- Necco wafers, Good n Plenty, Smarties ( I assume you mean the American ones and not the delicious Canadian Smarties which would be in my top 3.)

Oh, yeah. I meant the weird chalky American kind. I'll edit the OP to clarify.

Thought so. Those are gross. We call them Rockets here.

[polka]

Oct 31, 2012 18:17:37 GMT -5 kevin arnold said:

D'oh!!!! How did I leave out Kit Kats!!!

Lol I amend my answer to my top three as kit kat, peanut m & m's and snickers.

[annyong]

Sweet! See ya Reese's!

[kellykapowski]

RUDE! I'll eat all your necco wafers, then. Hmph.

[PinkSquirrel]

Top 3 - Tootsie Rolls, Peanut M&Ms, and SkittlesSourPatchKidsStarburstSwedishFish (What? They're all chewy)

Bottom 3 - Good n Plenty, Mary Janes, Whoppers

[janiejones]

I ranked your list-
Reese's PB cups
Snickers
Twizzlers
Tootsie Rolls
Sour Patch Kids
Peanut M&Ms
Butterfingers
Starburst
M&Ms, original
Swedish Fish
Kit Kat

and these can all go in the trash:
Candy Corn
Dots
Dum Dums (your fav flavor)
Good n Plenty
Laffy Taffy
Mary Janes
Necco Wafers
Skittles
Smarties (American)
Whoppers

[missmaddie]

Fav:
Reese's PB Cups
Whoppers
Twizzlers

Least:
Candy corn
Good n Plenty
American Smarties +o(

Don't know what these are (Canadian... )
Dum Dums
Mary Janes
Necco Wafers

[janiejones]

Oct 31, 2012 18:16:11 GMT -5 bananapancakes said:

Oct 31, 2012 18:13:48 GMT -5 kevin arnold said:

Oh, yeah. I meant the weird chalky American kind. I'll edit the OP to clarify.

Thought so. Those are gross. We call them Rockets here.

In the 80s & 90s there was a candy *like* rockets/US smarties but was way more tart, and less powdery. It was shaped the same, and wrapped the same, but no logo on the wrapper. I loved those things. Rockets always disappointed me.

[lyssa1985]

Faves: Reese's PB Cups, Starburst, &
Swedish fish

Least faves: dots, candy corn, & snickers


Sent from my Milestone X using proboards

[PinkSquirrel]

Oct 31, 2012 18:28:28 GMT -5 kevin arnold said:

Oct 31, 2012 18:25:31 GMT -5 PinkSquirrel said:

Top 3 - Tootsie Rolls, Peanut M&Ms, and SkittlesSourPatchKidsStarburstSwedishFish (What? They're all chewy)

Bottom 3 - Good n Plenty, Mary Janes, Whoppers

I'm with you on the fruity chewy stuff. I'm a sucker for skittles and starbursts. But you know what's hanging around as imposter tart fruity chewy goodness? Laffy taffy. I just choked down one of those thinking it was gonna be like an airhead. Nope. That shit is nasty.

Laffy Taffy is no Airhead. Airheads are one of my favorites and Laffy Taffy was on the short list for my bottom three

[roadbananas]

Kit Kats
Candy Corn
AND WHERE IS THE CRUNCH BAR??!


NO: Goodn plenty, mary janes and necco wafers

[sterl724]

Top 3:
Sour patch kids
Kit kat
Starburst


Bottom 3:
Candy corn - I HATE it
Necco wafers
Swedish fish

[hisno1girl]

Top 3
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups (The pumpkins are even better)
Snickers
Kit Kat

Bottom 8 (because I hate all of these candies)
Candy Corn, Dots, Dum Dums (your fav flavor), Good n Plenty, Sour Patch Kids, Swedish Fish, Tootsie Rolls, Twizzlers.

[missyny]

I just laughed so hard...and still am ...at "Satan's. Asshole "


Aaaaaand I agree btw

[dragonfly08]

Top three, in no particular order: Kit Kat, PB cups, Butterfingers (which my kids got *none* of this year...bummer!).

Bottom - pretty much everything else on the list except for candy corn, Whoppers, Snickers, and M&Ms. I absolutely hate anything sticky/chewy or chalky.

[rex]

3 best: peanut m&ms, pb cups, sp kids

3 worst: Candy Corn, Butterfinger, Whopper

This was hard because I hate
most candy, and the 5ish that I do like, I REALLY like.

[julesf84]

Top 3:
1. Peanut M&Ms
2. Snickers
3. Kit Kats

Least Faves:
1. Dots
2. Starburst
3. Good n Plenty

[flex]

YUMS!
Reese's PB cups
Skittles
Tootsie Rolls



BARFS!
Candy Corn
Good n Plenty
Smarties (American)

[gretchenindisguise]

Top 3: Starburst, Swedish Fish, and Dots (green are my fave flavor).

Bottom 3: Anything with chocolate or peanuts.

This is why it rocked as a kid - everyone hated the ones I could eat. Yum!!